Capital Management Techniques in Developing Countries: An Assessment of Experiences from the 1990's and Lessons for the Future

Abstract

This paper uses the term, capital management techniques, to refer to two complementary (and often overlapping) types of financial policies: policies that govern international private capital flows and those that enforce prudential management of domestic financial institutions. The paper shows that regimes of capital management take diverse forms and are multi-faceted. The paper also shows that capital management techniques can be static or dynamic. Static management techniques are those that authorities do not modify in response to changes in circumstances. Capital management techniques can also be dynamic, meaning that they can be activated or adjusted as circumstances warrant. Three types of circumstances trigger implementation of management techniques or lead authorities to strengthen or adjust existing regulations--changes in the economic environment, the identification of vulnerabilities, and the attempt to close loopholes in existing measures.The paper presents seven case studies of the diverse capital management techniques employed in Chile, Colombia, Taiwan Province of China, India, China, Singapore and Malaysia during the 1990s. The cases reveal that policymakers were able to use capital management techniques to achieve critical macroeconomic objectives. These included the prevention of maturity and locational mismatch; attraction of favored forms of foreign investment; reduction in overall financial fragility, currency risk, and speculative pressures in the economy; insulation from the contagion effects of financial crises; and enhancement of the autonomy of economic and social policy. The paper examines the structural factors that contributed to these achievements, and also weighs the costs associated with these measures against their macroeconomic benefits.The paper concludes by considering the general policy lessons of these seven experiences. The most important of these lessons are as follows. 1.) Capital management techniques can enhance overall financial and currency stability, buttress the autonomy of macro and micro-economic policy, and bias investment toward the long-term. 2.) The efficacy of capital management techniques is highest in the presence of strong macroeconomic fundamentals, though management techniques can also improve fundamentals. 3.) The nimble, dynamic application of capital management techniques is an important component of policy success. 4.) Controls over international capital flows and prudential domestic financial regulation often function as complementary policy tools, and these tools can be useful to policymakers over the long run. 5.) State and administrative capacity play important roles in the success of capital management techniques. 6.) Evidence suggests that the macroeconomic benefits of capital management techniques probably outweigh their microeconomic costs. 7.) Capital management techniques work best when they are coherent and consistent with a national development vision. 8.) There is no single type of capital management technique that works best for a...

Exchange rate management techniques

“…It's worth to recalling that during the 1990s, up to the emerging countries crises, when the exchange rate managed regimes (fixed or exchange bands) prevailed, some of these countries adopted the same two kind of regulatory instruments, which integrated what Epstein, Grabel and Jomo (2004) called "Capital management techniques". These techniques include the traditional menu of capital controls but add a set of prudential financial regulations (as restrictions on banks operations in foreign currencies).…”

The Political Economy of Reducing the United States Dollar’s Role as a Global Reserve Currency

“…Another option is implementing capital controls, which have proven be effective in several economies (see for example Epstein, Grabel, and Jomo, 2004). However, with the advent of greater financial integration, capital controls, particularly on inflows, have to be endorsed at the international level to be effective (Grenville, 2007).…”

Inflation Targeting, Employment Creation and Economic Development: Assessing the Impacts and Policy Alternatives

“…From our perspective, the real crux of the problem turns out to be one leg of this 'tri-lemma", namely the fact that orthodox economists, by and large, have taken for granted that eliminating capital controls is the best policy, and that virtually complete financial liberalization with respect to the foreign sector is the optimal policy. Yet recent evidence amply shows that open capital markets can create very costly problems for developing countries and that many successful developing countries have used a variety of capital management techniques to manage these flows in order, among other things, to help them escape this so-called "trilemma" (Ocampo, 2004;Epstein, Grabel and Jomo, K.S., 2005).…”