Can the modernisation of a public employment service be an effective labour market intervention? The Hungarian experience, 2004-2008

Abstract

The Public Employment Service often delivers much of the employment policy including active labour market programmes in many member states in the EU, yet we know little about its effectiveness in general. This paper provides a quantitative assessment of the potential impact of the modernisation programme of the Hungarian Public Employment service between 2004 and 2008. Using data at the level of local offices, I calculate programme effects using a difference-in-difference estimator. Results show that the programme has increased re-employment rates significantly, by 6%. The modernisation was thus a moderately effective but relatively inexpensive intervention, similar in terms of cost-effectiveness to the better active labour market programmes in Hungary.

A job trial subsidy for youth: Cheap labour or a screening device?

“…Cumulative earnings were higher by about 61% of the minimum wage for job trial participants during the 6 months after completing the programme 17 . There may be an upward bias in these estimates, considering that the public works programme might have a negative impact on employment outcomes on the primary labour market (see Caliendo & Schmidl, 2016 for international evidence and Cseres‐Gergely & Molnár, 2015, Köllő & Scharle, 2012 specifically for Hungary. )…”

“…Most participants work full time, which leaves little time for job search, increasing the risk of lock-in. The existing evaluations (though not fully eliminating endogeneity and selection bias) indeed show that the programme does not improve the likelihood of reemployment and has failed to reduce long-term unemployment at the settlement level (see for exampleKöll} o & Scharle, 2012, Cseres-Gergely & Molnár, 2015.…”

Escaping From the Poverty Trap With Social Innovation: A Social Microcredit Programme in Hungary

“…2) The extension of public work schemes in 2009 and their massive expansion from 2012 (after a sudden decline in 2011; Cseres-Gergely and Molnár 2014Molnár , 2015 further decreased the risk-taking propensity of the unemployed.…”

Evaluation of Labor Market Programs During Recession in the North Great Plain Region of Hungary

“…In the EU Employment Summit's proposal (2009), three main policies were recommended: to save existing jobs and create new ones; to provide training and improve the match between labor market demand and supply; to improve employment odds (Cseres-Gergely & Scharle, 2009). Under these circumstances more and more action plans have come into force to require active governmental measures both in high-and medium-income countries.…”