Business-Like and Still Serving Society? Investigating the Relationship Between NPOs Being Business-Like and Their Societal Roles

Abstract

Nonprofit organizations (NPOs) becoming business-like is a contested issue. Some understand the adoption of business-like practices by NPOs as a case of adopting rational myths through institutional isomorphism and thus potentially dangerous for NPOs’ ability to fulfill their unique societal roles. Others are more optimistic, arguing that technical rationality is possible in the adoption of business-like practices, and that such practices can therefore support NPOs in fulfilling a wide range of societal roles. Drawing on survey data of NPOs in Flanders, we examine the relationship between the extent to which NPOs use business-like practices, and the extent to which they engage in various societal roles. We find that business-like practices are weakly related to NPOs’ societal roles. All roles are positively related to nonprofit managerialism and unrelated to NPOs’ reliance on commercial funding. Our results suggest that a certain optimism regarding the rational use of business-like approaches is justified.

Donors' giving decisions toward nonprofit commercialization: Do commercial form and intensity matter?

“…First, analysis of the NCCS data learns that this is above the average for the forest conservation NPOs subsector. Second, nonprofit management studies increasingly report that nonprofit commercialization is susceptible to a too much of a good thing effect (Suykens et al, 2023). Essentially, nonprofit commercialization can increase organizational survival‐ (Gras & Mendoza‐Abarca, 2014) and donation likelihood up to a certain tipping point (Lee et al, 2021).…”

Communal focused or market focused: Moral judgment on business practices in nonprofit organizations

“…In comparison, most people may consider traditional nonprofit activities to be communal focused. Previous literature has proposed several practices that demonstrate nonprofits' societal roles, including public service delivery, political advocacy, community building, and civic engagement (Frumkin, 2009; Ivanova & Neumayr, 2017; Moulton & Eckerd, 2012; Suykens et al, 2022). All of these practices focus on unconditional support and sharing with members in a community or building a sense of community with trust and inclusion.…”

Greening Austrian social service and healthcare non-profits

“…As a consequence of NPM, the financial risk for providing SSHC-services has been transferred from public funders to the service-providers. In corporatist, liberal and social welfare states alike, SSHC-NPOs have adopted business-style management practices to increase their managerial professionalism, and to become more entrepreneurial [ 19 , 13 , 20 ]. Service-providing NPOs often face the accusation of pursuing financial goals at the expense of their social missions when they adopt corporate management practices.…”