Brain Mechanisms of Virtual Reality Breathing Versus Traditional Mindful Breathing in Pain Modulation: Observational Functional Near-infrared Spectroscopy Study

Abstract

Background Pain is a complex experience that involves sensory-discriminative and cognitive-emotional neuronal processes. It has long been known across cultures that pain can be relieved by mindful breathing (MB). There is a common assumption that MB exerts its analgesic effect through interoception. Interoception refers to consciously refocusing the mind’s attention to the physical sensation of internal organ function. Objective In this study, we dissect the cortical analgesic processes by imaging the brains of healthy subjects exposed to traditional MB (TMB) and compare them with another group for which we augmented MB to an outside sensory experience via virtual reality breathing (VRB). Methods The VRB protocol involved in-house–developed virtual reality 3D lungs that synchronized with the participants’ breathing cycles in real time, providing them with an immersive visual-auditory exteroception of their breathing. Results We found that both breathing interventions led to a significant increase in pain thresholds after week-long practices, as measured by a thermal quantitative sensory test. However, the underlying analgesic brain mechanisms were opposite, as revealed by functional near-infrared spectroscopy data. In the TMB practice, the anterior prefrontal cortex uniquely modulated the premotor cortex. This increased its functional connection with the primary somatosensory cortex (S1), thereby facilitating the S1-based sensory-interoceptive processing of breathing but inhibiting its other role in sensory-discriminative pain processing. In contrast, virtual reality induced an immersive 3D exteroception with augmented visual-auditory cortical activations, which diminished the functional connection with the S1 and consequently weakened the pain processing function of the S1. Conclusions In summary, our study suggested two analgesic neuromechanisms of VRB and TMB practices—exteroception and interoception—that distinctively modulated the S1 processing of the ascending noxious inputs. This is in line with the concept of dualism (Yin and Yang).

Brain Functional Alteration at Different Stages of Neuropathic Pain With Allodynia and Emotional Disorders

“…Corticotropin-releasing factor neurons of the mPFC project directly to the nucleus accumbens and increased activity in these neurons in the setting of NeuP facilitates behavioral responses to morphine reward ( 63 ). Interestingly, the practice of traditional mindful breathing was found to successfully modulate functional connectivity between the prefrontal and primary somatosensory cortices and relieve pain ( 64 ).…”

Reduced Pain by Mind-Body Intervention Correlates with Improvement of Shoulder Function in People with Shoulder Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial

“…Additionally, different types of breathing training such as virtual reality breathing and traditional mindful breathing also appear to improve pain thresholds. Interestingly, stimulation of different brain regions has been reported which varies depending on the breathing training method [ 48 ]. This suggests that breathing may have also independently affected pain regulation.…”

The Forefront of Dentistry—Promising Tech-Innovations and New Treatments

“…Furthermore, a recent study demonstrated a virtual reality breathing (VRB) protocol with virtual 3D-lungs that synchronized with the participants’ breathing cycles in real time, providing the participant with an immersive visual-auditory experience. When exposed to the VRB, the subjects decreased their pain sensitivity in the same manner as the participants using traditional meditative breathing but with opposing brain mechanisms for analgesia (Hu et al 2021). The rising visual-auditory sensations brought by the immersive VR experience cut off the connection between the competing pain inputs and a selective mind–body disconnection.…”