“…The equations have been shown to return unreliable results when applied to known storm or tsunami deposits, in particular underestimating storm wave power (e.g., Bourgeois and MacInnes, 2010;Switzer and Burston, 2010;Gandhi et al, 2017;Piscitelli et al, 2017). Despite these cautions, however, the Nott Approach continues to be applied for waveheight hindcasting (e.g., Vacchi et al, 2012;Mottershead et al, 2014;Biolchi et al, 2016;Boulton and Whitworth, 2017;Deguara and Gauci, 2017;Dewey and Ryan, 2017;Pepe et al, 2018;Kennedy et al, 2019;Roig-Munar et al, 2019). In consequence, the conversation about CBD is dominated by interpretations that, at best, are based on flawed methodology and, at worst, may be incorrect.…”