Bonding and Bridging Social Capital: Reflections from Belfast

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to question whether the concept of social capital has anything original to offer for understanding why some communities have weaker networks compared to others. Drawing on an empirical example from Belfast, the article illustrates that the themes embedded in social capital have a long history. Moreover, rather than a benign phenomenon, social capital excludes as well as includes community members within its networks. While Putnam (2000) tries to deal with this negative effect through his distinction between ‘bonding’ and ‘bridging’ social capital, his analysis is flawed. Moving from bonding to bridging social capital is beset with contradictions. In order to set in motion the framework for bridging social capital to emerge, the conditions that led to the development of bonding social capital need to be undermined. However, removing the rationale for the existence of bonding social capital by no means ensures that the path is paved for the development of bridging social capital.The article examines some of the problematic aspects of this transition through an examination of community networks and relationships in one Catholic community in West Belfast. Here, the wider political conflict in Northern Ireland facilitated the development of bonding social capital, while the peace process provided opportunities for bridging social capital to strengthen and develop. The example indicates that the exclusion aspect of social capital persists in the transition from bonding to bridging social capital.

How farmers’ characteristics influence spontaneous spreading of stone bunds in the highlands of Ethiopia: a case study in the Girar Jarso woreda

“…Particularly, a better contact with extension workers, active participation in extension programme and strong social relation demonstrate how much SF benefitted from bridging social capital. This type of social capital provides a means for farmers to access a wider information network, technical support and resources (Leonard 2004;Cramb 2005;Sanginga et al 2010). Similarly, farmers with more experience in IFM are more aware to spontaneously implement stone bunds integrated with more fertilizer, compost and manure using knowledge obtained from different sources.…”

Boom, Bust and Beyond: Arts and Sustainability in Calumet, Michigan

“…Scholarship suggests that such bonds among residents empower them to protect and pursue their collective interests [50][51][52][53][54]. Yet, bonding social capital can exclude individuals or groups and divide communities along economic, race, age, or other cultural lines [55,56]. In order to promote inclusive networks, bonding social capital must be balanced with bridging social capital [15,16,51,52,57].…”

Childhood in transition: growing up in ‘post-conflict’ Northern Ireland

“…Despite their difficult histories, communities are often galvanised and strengthened through challenging conflict and segregation (Leonard 2004;Smyth 2000). Cattell (2001) also notes that strong perceptions and experiences of inequality can be a uniting and/or empowering force in areas of deprivation.…”