The present article served as a follow-up to Tietze (2006), which explored the potential relevance of listening to Jazz as a tool for enhancing the undergraduate liberal arts educational experience. A holistic pedagogical structure, based on a model incorporating cognitive and emotional dimensions of experience and Erikson's (1997) theory of identity development, utilized recent developments in neuroscience including the brain's engagement in the process of creativity, and was applied to developing an undergraduate course titled, "Jazz and American Identity." For the present article, a case study approach was used to assess the process of learning through student response to this course. Several general themes emerged from the students' work, and a number of samples were summarized from end-of-term projects which explored a connection between an understanding of their own individual identity development in relationship to the semester's course content; a history of Jazz as metaphor for presentation of issues in American cultural development. Results indicated that a proactive approach toward combining play, art, and self-understanding forms an example of a creative process every human may engage in-the creation and development of one's unique identity. Themes for future research were also discussed; among them the use of anecdotal journal writing as data to "translate" listening and expressive skills to more clearly articulate human experience of emotional states, relationships between verbal and procedural memory, parallels between language and music processing, and connection between the worlds of science and the arts, especially the expansion of Jazz into a world-wide phenomenon.