Biological scaling analyses are more than statistical line fitting

Abstract

The magnitude of many biological traits relates strongly and regularly to body size. Consequently, a major goal of comparative biology is to understand and apply these ‘size-scaling’ relationships, traditionally quantified by using linear regression analyses based on log-transformed data. However, recently some investigators have questioned this traditional method, arguing that linear or non-linear regression based on untransformed arithmetic data may provide better statistical fits than log-linear analyses. Furthermore, they advocate the replacement of the traditional method by alternative specific methods on a case-by-case basis, based simply on best-fit criteria. Here, I argue that the use of logarithms in scaling analyses presents multiple valuable advantages, both statistical and conceptual. Most importantly, log-transformation allows biologically meaningful, properly scaled (scale-independent) comparisons of organisms of different size, whereas non-scaled (scale-dependent) analyses based on untransformed arithmetic data do not. Additionally, log-based analyses can readily reveal biologically and theoretically relevant discontinuities in scale invariance during developmental or evolutionary increases in body size that are not shown by linear or non-linear arithmetic analyses. In this way, log-transformation advances our understanding of biological scaling conceptually, not just statistically. I hope that my Commentary helps students, non-specialists and other interested readers to understand the general benefits of using log-transformed data in size-scaling analyses, and stimulates advocates of arithmetic analyses to show how they may improve our understanding of scaling conceptually, not just statistically.

How Metabolic Rate Relates to Cell Size

“…Shifts from cell multiplication to cell differentiation are sensitive to nutrient availability (as observed in fission yeast, Schizosaccharomyces pombe [ 218 ], and fruit fly ovaries [ 224 ]). Therefore, the body-mass scaling of metabolic rate may serve as a useful energetic indicator of major transitions during ontogenetic development (see also [ 9 , 98 , 99 , 104 , 225 , 226 ]). Rapid growth associated with cell multiplication is very expensive energetically, thus requiring large increases in metabolic rate, whereas the relatively slow growth associated with cell differentiation and/or expansion appears to be less costly energetically, thus requiring relatively small increases in metabolic rate (cf.…”

The size dependency of foraging behaviour: an empirical test performed on aquatic amphipods

“…The number of visits to type of patches (N) and number of visits to the resource patches only (N) during the whole experiment were used as a proxy for the individual cumulative space use and modelled as a function of the foragers individual body mass (mg DW). Since the relationships between body size and amount of space used are commonly formulated as a power law (Tamburello et al 2015;Glazier 2021), the response and the explanatory variable were logtransformed. The two time blocks of measurements were fitted as random terms.…”

Global congruence of riverine fish species richness and human presence

“…We related the catchment‐level fish species richness values to the covariates with a linear mixed effect model, using main basin identity as a random intercept to account for non‐independence of observations from catchments within the same main basin. We log 10 ‐transformed the fish species richness and the four discharge variables because of their skewed distribution and our focus on scaling relationships (Glazier, 2021; Ives, 2015). We also log 10 ‐transformed catchment area, elevation and precipitation because of their positive skew (Supporting Information Figures S2 and S3).…”