Beware of Selfies: The Impact of Photo Type on Impression Formation Based on Social Networking Profiles

Abstract

Users of social networking sites such as Facebook frequently post self-portraits on their profiles. While research has begun to analyze the motivations for posting such pictures, less is known about how selfies are evaluated by recipients. Although producers of selfies typically aim to create a positive impression, selfies may also be regarded as narcissistic and therefore fail to achieve the intended goal. The aim of this study is to examine the potentially ambivalent reception of selfies compared to photos taken by others based on the Brunswik lens model Brunswik (1956). In a between-subjects online experiment (N = 297), Facebook profile mockups were shown which differed with regard to picture type (selfie vs. photo taken by others), gender of the profile owner (female vs. male), and number of individuals within a picture (single person vs. group). Results revealed that selfies were indeed evaluated more negatively than photos taken by others. Persons in selfies were rated as less trustworthy, less socially attractive, less open to new experiences, more narcissistic and more extroverted than the same persons in photos taken by others. In addition, gender differences were observed in the perception of pictures. Male profile owners were rated as more narcissistic and less trustworthy than female profile owners, but there was no significant interaction effect of type of picture and gender. Moreover, a mediation analysis of presumed motives for posting selfies revealed that negative evaluations of selfie posting individuals were mainly driven by the perceived motivation of impression management. Findings suggest that selfies are likely to be evaluated less positively than producers of selfies might suppose.

Selfie addiction: The impact of personality traits? A cross‐sectional study among the Lebanese population

“…In the literature, openness to experience was positively associated with addictive selfie behavior, 52,53 contrary to our results that show that openness trait is related to low selfie‐taking behavior. This can be explained by the fact that an open person is known to be active, with a creative and innovative vision of the world, and ready to experience new things 54‐56 .…”

Is Impression Management Through Status Updates Successful? Meta-Accuracy and Judgment Accuracy of Big Five Personality Traits Based on Status Updates From Social Network Sites in China

“…In the case of perceivers, they may not completely trust the content of status updates. Krämer et al (2017) noted that observers become suspicious when they perceive “presenters” as motivated to manage impression of their selfies, and according to the lens model of Brunswik (1956), perceivers may take motives of the users into account in order to improve accuracy of perception.…”

Does Objectification on Social Media Cost Young Men?

“…Of note, interest in a committed dating relationship with Anthony was fairly low in both conditions. Recent research indicates that selfies are evaluated more negatively than a photo taken by someone else (Kramer et al, 2017). In addition, men who post selfies are thought to be more narcissistic and less trustworthy than women who post selfies.…”