Better workers, better elections? Electoral management body workforces and electoral integrity worldwide

Abstract

Building better elections is a central task for the study of democracy and democratisation. Despite this, there have been no cross-national studies on the staff who manage and implement elections: electoral management body (EMB) workforces. This article provides the first macroscopic worldwide picture of workforce characteristics, human resource management practices and employee outcomes, and analyses the effects they have on electoral integrity, based on original international surveys of electoral management bodies (EMBs) (n = 51) and electoral officials (n = 2029). Drawing from the human resource management literature, a framework is developed to explain how these factors might interact with EMB performance. Analysis demonstrates them to be highly related. Adding data on human resource management practices and employee outcomes improves explanatory models designed to predict the performance of EMBs. Chiefly, EMBs that enable greater opportunities for employees to be involved in decision-making processes perform better. Recruitment practices, job satisfaction and levels of stress are also important.

When Is It Democratic to Postpone an Election? Elections During Natural Disasters, COVID-19, and Emergency Situations

“…Emergencies can, however, pose major logistical problems which could force elections into major compromises, or even make them undeliverable. The delivery of elections is reliant on huge workforces in order to deliver an election (James 2019), which may suddenly not be available. Many countries rely on a temporary workforce close to election day to serve as poll workers, presiding officers, and poll clerks.…”

Integridad electoral y órganos electorales subnacionales en México: el papel de la imparcialidad

“…Los resultados también son consistentes con los argumentos sobre la importancia de la profesionalización del personal de servicios públicos en las elecciones (Clark, 2017;James, 2019). Contrario a la expectativa a priori, pero en línea con Garnett (2017), no se encontró una relación estrecha entre transparencia e integridad electoral.…”

Institutions of Electoral Integrity and Clientelism: The Role of Electoral Management Bodies

“…Studies on EMBs address, for example, the importance of staffing (James 2019), budget (Clark 2019), capacity , and, most frequently, autonomy (Mozaffar 2002;Birch 2008;Hartlyn et al 2008;van Ham and Lindberg 2015b;Kerr and Lürhmann 2017;van Ham and Garnett 2019). In the majority of studies, these aspects of EMBs exhibit important effects on the quality of elections and democracy.…”