Benefits of threshold strategies and age-selective harvesting in a fluctuating fish stock of Norwegian spring spawning herring Clupea harengus

Abstract

The current state of the world's fisheries resources requires further investigation into the means and methods for sustainable use of fish stocks. In this study, I assess the performance of different harvesting strategies on a population model developed for Norwegian spring spawning herring Clupea harengus, a stock historically known as one of the largest and most valuable fish stocks in the world. This stock is further characterized by strong long-term fluctuations in stock size, which considerably complicate successful population management. The results support the use of threshold strategies, where harvesting is only allowed if the population size of the target population is above a predetermined threshold. Threshold strategies are beneficial for maintaining spawning biomass, yield, and prevention of population collapse. The downside of a threshold approach is the fisheries moratoria associated with low stock size. To overcome this, I introduce a precautionary strategy including 2 thresholds for reducing the likelihood and length of moratoria, such that if the population size decreases below an upper threshold, the harvest ratio is decreased in order to achieve fast recovery to the target population size. I also test the effect of changing the timing of fish entering the harvestable stock by means of age-selective harvesting. I show that allowing reproduction, preferably more than once, before the fish become vulnerable to harvesting increases the spawning biomass and yield, and decreases the variability in yield and the risk of stock collapse.KEY WORDS: Harvesting strategy · Threshold · Norwegian spring spawning herring · Age-selective harvesting · Precautionary strategy Resale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisher

Stability of International Fisheries Agreements Using Precautionary Bioeconomic Harvesting Strategies

“…The biological benefits of precautionary threshold strategy have been confirmed earlier (Enberg 2005) but our results support the use them also on economic grounds.…”

A review of harvest policies: Understanding relative performance of control rules

“…This approach is relatively flexible in that the relative influence of average yield and the standard deviation of yield can be controlled using the weighting term, . An alternative, but less commonly used type of risk-averse objective accounts for how frequently or over what duration biomass or harvests have been at or below a threshold (Enberg, 2005;Irwin et al, 2008).…”

Evaluation of threshold management strategies for groundfish off the U.S. West Coast

“…For example, Quinn et al (1990) and Zheng and Quinn (1993) examined the performance of threshold management strategies and determined the threshold values that maximized an objective function that consisted of a linear combination of the average annual yield and its standard deviation. Enberg (2005) examined a range of threshold management strategies for the particular case of Norwegian spring spawning herring Clupea harengus, includ-1 'Stock size' is expressed in units intended to closely capture the reproductive output of the population, such as egg production or spawning biomass.…”