Beijing Cultural and Creative Industry policy effect evaluation based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation

Lu, Chao; Chang, Jialu

doi:10.1007/s10586-016-0662-x

Cited by 16 publications

(10 citation statements)

References 3 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…With regards the broader effects on territorial systems, for example, there are important issues related to the role that clusters play in structural change or in smart specialization strategies, and to the impacts of clusters on the capacity to tackle social challenges (“beyond GDP”) (Wilson, 2019). There are also clear opportunities from engaging further with some of the new approaches to evaluating cluster policies that are emerging, such as analysis of social media networks (Etxabe, 2018), or a stronger combination of case‐oriented and quantitative analysis through the adaption of fuzzy‐set qualitative comparative analysis for cluster evaluation (Lu & Chang, 2016; Ragin, 2000). Leveraging and connecting the different types of data collected by policy‐makers over sustained periods of time could also support more widespread and consistent analysis of the types of behavioural elements of cluster networks that are starting to be explored (Felzensztein et al, 2018; Graf & Broekel, 2020; Lucena‐Piquero & Vicente, 2019).…”

Section: Discussionmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…In this context Schmiedeberg (2010, p. 404) concludes by warning against the use of single evaluation methods which she argues can only “provide a very limited view on the cluster policy programme.” This is echoed in Aranguren et al’s (2014) arguments for mixed methods and is reflected in various studies experimenting with innovative approaches. These include the application of systems thinking (Smith & Brown, 2009), participatory evaluation (Aragón, Aranguren, Diez, Iturrioz, & Wilson, 2014), fuzzy comprehensive evaluation (Lu & Chang, 2016), social network analysis (Giuliani & Pietrobelli, 2016) and novel forms of social capital measurement (Etxabe, 2018). Most studies in this emerging literature are fundamentally concerned with understanding the relational dynamics fostered by cluster policies and exploring their impacts.…”

Section: Cluster Evaluation: Some Contextmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Evaluating clusters: Where theory collides with practice

Smith

Wilson

Wise

2020

Regional Science Policy & Practice

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Cluster policies are widely used to strengthen regional competitiveness, yet difficult to evaluate. While academic approaches to cluster evaluation are often ignorant of the needs of policy‐makers and practitioners, practitioner‐led approaches often lack structure and rigour. As such, there remain significant gaps between theory and practice. The contribution of this paper is to reflect on a unique methodological approach that has regularly brought together academics, policy‐makers and practitioners from around the world to collectively address the challenges of cluster evaluation. A participatory process of integrating theory and practice highlights the importance of triple helix engagement to co‐design evaluation of what is a triple helix policy proposition.

show abstract

Section: Discussionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Cluster Evaluation: Some Contextmentioning

confidence: 99%

Evaluating clusters: Where theory collides with practice

Smith

Wilson

Wise

2020

Regional Science Policy & Practice

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…As a strategic emerging industry, CCIs can stimulate industry restructuring, transform economic growth, and lead to the development of new and ecofriendly cities. Lu and Chang (2016) established a political effect evaluation system for CCIs in Beijing that defines weight with entropy and analyzes its effect through fuzzy comprehensive evaluation. They concluded that industry policies have been effectively implemented in Beijing and that the beneficial effects on society and culture have consistently increased, particularly the economic benefits.…”

Section: Evaluating the Performance Of Cultural And Creative Industriesmentioning

confidence: 99%

Integrated Approach for Exploring Critical Elements That Affect Sustainable Development of Cultural and Creative Industries

Lin

2021

Journal of Business Economics and Management

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The cultural and creative industries (CCIs) are increasingly regarded as a means to cure economic stagnation and boost sustainable development; thus, they have become the focus of cultural, social, and economic policies. This study adopts a city governance perspective to explore topics that should be considered in CCIs development. We combine entropy weight and grey relational analysis into an evaluation indicator system that considers ambiguity and complexity. The results reveal the cities in the eastern region and offshore islands took more advantage of investment in cultural resources than cities in the western region. It indicates that local governments understand that the economic benefits of culture are not limited to certain CCIs but extend to the overall economy. Through stimulus policies, communities have been built and effectively revitalized regional economies. The developed method prioritizes the provision of cultural and creative resources to effectively improve resource–generating capacity of a city. This study provides suggestions for decision makers in cultural and creative sectors to help them overcome the gap in resource allocation between urban and rural areas.

show abstract

“…The creative industry-based tourism potentials are richly available in both urban and rural areas, particularly in rural areas (Evans, 2009;Dorry, Rosol & Thissen, 2016;Lu & Chang, 2016). In the case of the study area, the rural area reserves the perspectives of the industry along with cultural and natural based tourism potentials, for example, in the buffer areas of Surakarta City.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Integrated Planning Model of Creative Industry-Based Kampung Tourism in Jayengan Surakarta, Indonesia

Astuti

Permana

Qomarun³

et al. 2017

PMJ

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Creative Industry-based tourism has been popular as several cities in Indonesia have also been declared as "Creative City". In sustainability viewpoint, the integration of creative industry activities with other planning elements and efforts towards social and economic development is necessary. The inter-organizational collaboration is essential by integrating various disciplines in managing the complexity and the dynamics in tourism development. This research aims at developing an Integrated Planning Model of Creative Industry-based Tourism in Jayengan Surakarta. The study adopted a mixed-methods approach using detailed observations and interviews, as well as Focus Group Discussion (FGD) with the primary actors to understand the process. The study suggests that creative industry-based kampung tourism in Jayengan Surakarta, must be developed with integrated manner through interrelationships among tourism components, developing problem-solving model, promoting a conceptual system to guide the process and strengthening the inter-organizational collaboration. It is also understood that this concept might promote rural development since the potential sources of local industries and tourism are abundantly available in the rural areas.

show abstract

Beijing Cultural and Creative Industry policy effect evaluation based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation

Cited by 16 publications

References 3 publications

Evaluating clusters: Where theory collides with practice

Evaluating clusters: Where theory collides with practice

Integrated Approach for Exploring Critical Elements That Affect Sustainable Development of Cultural and Creative Industries

Integrated Planning Model of Creative Industry-Based Kampung Tourism in Jayengan Surakarta, Indonesia

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About