Becoming a critical narrativist: Using critical reflection and narrative inquiry as research methodology

Abstract

This article explores the process of combining narrative inquiry and critical reflection as research methodology. Qualitative researchers use narrative approaches to explore the stories of participants and to understand the ways these stories were constructed and positioned. Critical reflection provides a framework for deconstructing the stories and exploring assumptions about knowledge, power and reflexivity. In this PhD research, the narrative approach was underpinned by, and combined with, a critically reflective research approach. As these approaches were amalgamated, the critical narrativist emerged. Principles of critical reflection and narrative scholarship can be intertwined; however, the separate threads may be conceptually and practically separated. This article describes how these modes of inquiry came together and discusses the implicit and explicit nature of the methodological positions. Finally, the author considers the opportunities for being more explicit about combining critical reflection with other research methodological approaches.

Other Ways of Knowing: The Intersection of Education when Researching Family Roots

“…By using the stories of individual participants, Cooper and Hughes (2015) stated that individuals are able to identify and create a sense of self-hood. Hickson (2016) noted that critical reflection adds to narrative inquiry and provides a way for participants to explore their own stories and this deepens an understanding of a central idea. To me, genealogy is about finding the truth (or not) of family stories and learning how these stories are interpreted.…”

Community engagement in youth justice program design

“…The narrative interviewing process involves engaging with people’s stories about their experiences and is useful in understanding individual’s life path, by attempting to understand the participants’ words, rather than predicting or explaining them (Anderson & Kirkpatrick, 2015; Giovanna et al., 2019). This approach allows for the exploration of experiences and situations to uncover new meanings for the interviewer and participant (Hickson, 2016). The narrative interviewing approach was informed by the interviewer’s understanding of ‘yarning’, described by other researchers as a culturally responsive and rigorous methodology.…”

Teachers as Ethnographers: Narrative Study of Inquiry of Indonesian Teachers Assigned to Teach in Remote Areas

“…As an approach, narrative inquiry aims to dismantle "relational complexities and nuances of individuals and settings in varied contexts" (Macintyre et al, 2018). Therefore, researchers must be able to capture holistically the narratives of individuals/participants (Hickson, 2016) so that the obtained stories produce a deep scientific reflectivity.…”