Be successful – be male and masculine? On the influence of gender roles on objective career success

Abstract

Purpose -The purpose of the paper is to analyse the influence of individual gender role specifications on objective career success (measured by gross yearly income) in the context of different gender job contexts whilst controlling for human capital and working time variables. Typical economic, sociological and psychological variables are combined to improve explanations of the gender wage gap. Design/methodology/approach -Starting from Eagly and Karau's role incongruity theory, the paper derives hypotheses on the influence of gender role specification, gender job context and biological sex on gross yearly income. These hypotheses are analysed by logistic regressions with a data set from Germany. The paper presents results of a quantitative empirical survey of employees on wages, gender role-related self-descriptions and human capital variables. Findings -The paper results show that even in this highly qualified sample, male biological sex, masculine gender roles and non-female job context have a positive effect on individual income. The results hold true when the paper controls for human capital, working time, professional experience and jobs in the public sector. Research limitations/implications -Because of the limited size of the data set and some problems with selectivity, the research results lack generalizability. Researchers are thus encouraged to test the propositions with other data sets. Practical implications -The paper includes implications for wage design and for reaching wage equality in firms. An important implication for policy and practice is that under a gender and equal opportunity perspective, ensuring non-discriminating behaviour with regard to women may be only one (albeit an important) element of equal opportunity activities. Equal wage policies should further consider the gender characteristics of the job context, which may influence job-related roles and thus role incongruities. Additionally, individual interpretations of gender roles might have effects on wages. Human resource (HR) managers could support such policies by shaping job descriptions carefully with regard to gender role aspects, by influencing the gender composition of job contexts and by paying attention to the individual development of gender role interpretations in HR development programmes. Originality/value -The paper fulfils an identified research need to study simultaneously the influence of human capital variables and gender roles on wages. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first study, which studies the influence of gender roles as defined by Born (1992) on income in a German context of highly qualified individuals while controlling for human capital, working time and professional experience. The existing lack in the literature with regard to empirical analyses on the combined influence of economic, sociological and psychological variables is mitigated.

Personality and pay: do gender gaps in confidence explain gender gaps in wages?

“…It would be enlightening for future research to more closely investigate the quantifiable links between personality traits and performance, so as to discern the extent to which 'typical male traits' merit higher labour market returns, or whether the higher remuneration attached to these traits are a vestige of other factors such as job role stereotyping or gender differences in negotiation styles (Alewell, 2013). Equally, it is worth investigating why a 'typical female trait' such as agreeableness is not remunerated more highly in the labour market, given the value of teamwork and cooperation in many workplace settings.…”

The impact of gender and profit margin on the duration of hiring process for professional service firms

“…A common perception may be that much progress has been made on the equality between the sexes front (Stoker et al , 2012). However, results from this research, along with recent reports such as the anti-diversity manifesto from a Google employee (McGregor, 2017), as well as findings on gender-related personality phenomena (Alewell, 2013; Georgellis and Sankae, 2016; Kang et al , 2015) all illustrate that there is more work to be done on this issue.…”

The Relationship Between Workplace Burnout and Male Depression Symptom Assessed by the Korean Version of the Gotland Male Depression Scale

“…Characteristics of subjects in specific studies can also affect the results. Gender roles have been reported to be related to occupational state and studies conducted within similar socioeconomic states, such as in the same workspace or the same university reduce the difference in gender roles between men and women ( Alewell, 2013 ; Lipińska-Grobelny & Wasiak, 2010 ). The current study was performed in a male-dominated public institution and female workers may have more masculine traits than the general population.…”