Banks’ risk culture and management control systems: A systematic literature review

Abstract

Over ten years of a debate about the best ways to make banks safer have led to the conclusion that improving their risk culture is one venue to achieve this goal. Consequently, different disciplines discuss topics related to risk culture from varying methodological angles. This effort of many scholars provides a rich basis of theoretical and empirical evidence to guide business practice and improve regulation. However, the application of many approaches and methods can result in fragmentation and loss of a comprehensive perspective. This paper strives to counteract this fragmentation by providing a comprehensive perspective focusing particularly on the embeddedness of risk culture into banks’ management control systems. In order to achieve this goal, we apply a systematic literature review and interpret the identified findings through the theoretical lens of management control research. This review identifies 103 articles, which can be structured along three categories: Assessment of risk culture, relation between risk culture and management controls (with the subcategories embeddedness of risk culture in overall management control packages, risk culture and cultural controls, risk culture and action controls, risk culture and results controls, as well as risk culture and personnel controls) and development of banks’ risk culture over time. Along these categories the identified findings are interpreted and synthesized to a comprehensive model and consequences for theory, business practice and regulation are derived.

Unraveling the Fintech Landscape: A Systematic Mapping Study on the Impact of Financial Technology Innovation on Investment Decision-Making in ASEAN Banking

“…Most of the time, banks play the role of an intermediary between their clientele, who need financial resources, and those who themselves need such resources. Banks must manage risks associated with financial operations just as they handle risks associated with any other business operation (Kunz & Heitz, 2021). In addition, banks are crucial to a country's economic development because they facilitate the availability of capital and lend backing to businesses and initiatives that can contribute to that development.…”

Bibliometric And Literature Review Of Financing Risk In Islamic Banking

“…Pengelolaan risiko pada perbankan telah mengalami peningkatan sejalan dengan perkembangan industri keuangan secara keseluruhan (Kunz and Heitz 2021). Dalam beberapa tahun terakhir, perbankan mulai memahami pentingnya pengelolaan risiko untuk menjaga stabilitas dan kelangsungan bisnis.…”

Evolution of Risks Facing Commercial Banks in Kenya and Associated Strategic Responses

“…They also suggested that ownership structure and its impact on the performance of banks need to be investigated further. Kunz and Heitz (2021) performed a systematic literature review of banks' risk culture and management control systems. They interpreted the findings through the theoretical lens of management control research and synthesized them to a comprehensive model.…”