‘Bad Mothers’ and ‘Delinquent Children’: Unravelling anti-begging rhetoric in the Ecuadorian Andes

Abstract

In this paper I examine the rhetorics that circulate surrounding the lives of young indigenous women and children who beg on the streets of Quito, Ecuador. I focus particularly on rhetorics being produced and reproduced by urban planners, social workers, religious leaders and the media. Drawing on in-depth interviews, I reveal how these groups regularly imagine indigenous women and children in terms of child exploitation/child delinquency, false manipulation of public sympathies, ignorance, laziness and filth. Indigenous women and children are further understood as being fundamentally 'out of place' in the city. I unravel these rhetorics in order to draw attention to how begging is differentiated according to gender, race and age and to reveal how these rhetorics become inserted into exclusionary policies and practices. Moreover, and as a counterpoint to such rhetorics, I provide an alternative understanding of women's and children's involvement in begging by drawing upon the perspectives of indigenous women and children themselves. I argue that far from being passive victims, indigenous women and children work with and around oppressive conditions and mobilise them to their own advantage.

Conducting sensitive research in the present and past tense: Recounting the stories of current and former child domestic workers

“…Thirteen of the papers were in 'human geography' journals and/or published by authors who identified as geographers in their institutional affiliation (Abebe, 2007; 2008; Aitken et al, 2006;Bromley and Mackie, 2008;Dyson, 2008;Evans, 2006;Hastadewi, 2009;Jennings et al, 2006;Robson et al, 2006;Swanson, 2007;van Blerk, 2007;. Within the limitations of the database search parameters, this observation suggests that geographers have published, with some regularity, on research with working children in the Majority World.…”

Definitional Paradox and Legal Heterogeneity: Towards a Comprehensive and Operational Definition of Begging

“…Begging itself generally refers to a public request for money, food, or other goods, with little or nothing of value given in return (Lankenau, ,b; Snow & Anderson, ; Van Houcke, ). It is also generally agreed that this non‐reciprocated gift places the beggar outside the gift‐exchange theory structure (Swanson, ). This asymmetrical relationship places the beggar in an awkward position.…”

Cities on edge: Smuggling and neoliberal policies at the Iguazú triangle

“…In the urban Latin American context, the influence of neoliberalism is tangible in the (re)definition and governance of public space. The implementation of various policies – from gentrifying historical centres and ‘whitening’ their users to slum upgrading to the operationalization of ‘iron fist’ policies to halt criminality – have reordered relations between the citizenry, the (international) private sector and the state (Hume, 2007; Swanson, 2007; Aguiar, 2009; Nuijten & Koster, 2012). Zero‐tolerance policies, including various ‘wars’ on drugs, piracy and delinquency, have mushroomed all across the region, often functioning as part of programmes to enforce the regime of legality engendered by neoliberalism.…”