“…ASA is even negative in 2015 due to the strong doming in the upper 200 m. As both mode-water eddies have about the same propagation speed and 25 volume, the differences of water mass properties point towards seasonal or interannual variations of the water mass characteristics during their formation. The MWE is generated in February, when upwellingfavorable alongshore winds weaken and SST increases (Gutiérrez et al, 2011), whereas the mode-water Stramma et al (2014) is generated in April, when the PCUC, which transports oxygen-deficient ESSW (Hormazabal et al, 2013), has its poleward maximum (Shaffer et al, 1999;Penven et al, 2005;Chaigneau et al, 2013). Additionally, the mode-water eddy observed by Stramma et al (2014) was generated in year 2011, which is considered as a La Niña-period, when generally lower oxygen and higher salinity values exist in the upper 100 m depth (Stramma et al, 2016) leading 5 to higher anomalies of salt and oxygen of the MWE observed by Stramma et al (2014) in comparison to the actual MWE.…”