Augmenting Landmarks During the Head-Up Provision of In-Vehicle Navigation Advice

Abstract

The use of landmarks during the provision of directions can greatly improve drivers' route-following performance. However, the successful integration of landmarks within in-vehicle navigation systems is predicated on the acquisition and deployment of good quality landmarks, as defined by their visibility, uniqueness, permanence, location etc., and their accurate and succinct depiction on in-vehicle displays and during accompanying verbal messages. Notwithstanding the inherent variability in the quality and propensity of landmarks within the driving environment, attending to in-vehicle displays and verbal messages while driving can distract drivers and heighten their visual and cognitive workload. Furthermore, vocal utterances are transient and can be littered with paralinguistic cues that can influence a driver's interpretation of what is said. In this paper, a driving simulator study is described aiming to investigate the augmentation of landmarks during the head up provision of route guidance advice – a potential solution to some of these problems. Twenty participants undertook four drives utilising a navigation system presented on a head up display (HUD) in which navigational instructions were presented as either: conventional distance-to-turn information; on-road arrows; or augmented landmarks (either an arrow pointing to the landmark or a box enclosing the landmark adjacent to the required turning). Participants demonstrated significant performance improvements while using the augmented landmark 'box' compared to the conventional distance-to-turn information, with response times and success rates enhanced by 43.1% and 26.2%, respectively. Moreover, there were significant reductions in eyes off-the-road time when using this approach, and it also attracted the lowest subjective ratings of workload. The authors conclude that there are significant benefits to augmenting landmarks during the head-up provision of in-car navigation advice.

An Investigation of the Effects of Driver Age When Using Novel Navigation Systems in a Head-Up Display

“…More than a decade ago, Levy, Dascalu, & Harris (2005) and Narzt, Pomberger, Ferscha, Kolb, Müller, Wieghardt et al (2006) proposed technologies that project coloured lines onto the road ahead for drivers to follow. Large, Burnett, & Bolton (2017) observed improvements in navigation performance when using AR to highlight landmarks as cues. The benefits of using HUDs for driving and navigation are well documented in the literature (cf.…”

A toolbox for automated driving on the STISIM driving simulator

“…STISIM is a popular driving simulator that is used for research purposes [ [36] , [37] , [38] , [39] , [40] , [41] ]. The STISIM driving simulator software comes with an ‘Automated Driving’ feature accessible through its Scenario Definition Language (SDL) [ 42 , 43 ].…”