Achieving high product selectivities is one challenge that limits viability of electrochemical CO2 reduction (CO2R) to chemical feedstocks. Here, it was demonstrated how interactions between Ag foil cathodes and reline (choline chloride + urea) led to highly selective CO2R to CO with a faradaic efficiency of (96±8) % in 50 wt % aqueous reline at −0.884 V vs. the reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE), which is a 1.5‐fold improvement over CO2R in KHCO3. In reline the Ag foil was roughened by (i) dissolution of oxide layers followed by (ii) electrodeposition of Ag nanoparticles back on cathode. This surface restructuring exposed low‐coordinated Ag atoms, and subsequent adsorption of choline ions and urea at the catalyst surface limited proton availability in the double layer and stabilized key intermediates such as *COOH. These approaches could potentially be extended to other electrocatalytic metals and lower‐viscosity deep eutectic solvents to achieve higher‐current‐density CO2R in continuous‐flow cell electrolyzers.