Associations Between Maternal-Foetal Attachment and Infant Developmental Outcomes: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Objectives Infant developmental outcomes may be influenced by a range of prenatal maternal characteristics. While there is some evidence to suggest that maternal-foetal attachment may be associated with infant developmental outcomes, there is a need to systematically review this evidence to guide future research and clinical practice. Methods Five electronic databases were systematically scanned. Key journals and reference lists were hand-searched. Papers were included if: (1) pregnant women were assessed for maternal-foetal attachment; (2) the infants were later assessed, under 2 years old, for any developmental outcome (e.g., social-emotional, cognition, motor, language, adaptive behaviour); and (3) they were published in English. Two independent reviewers used the STROBE checklist to appraise the quality of each paper. Results Of the 968 papers identified, eight were included in the review, and four of these were of low quality (<60 %) based on the STROBE. The developmental domains that were examined included: infant temperament (n = 5), adaptive behaviour (e.g., colic, sleep) (n = 2), and milestone attainment (n = 1). There is some evidence to suggest that lower maternal-foetal attachment is related to suboptimal developmental outcomes. However, these results should be interpreted with caution due to the limited and low quality studies available. Conclusions Although maternal-foetal attachment may be associated with infant developmental outcomes, future research is required which: (1) considers a range of developmental outcomes, (2) has increased scientific rigour, (3) assesses mother-infant dyads at different prenatal and postnatal time points, and (4) examines different target populations.

Depression and parenting: the need for improved intervention models

“…As such, the womb is a child's first environment and fetal life is the beginning of the parent-child relationship albeit via complex biochemical and psychological interactions. One interesting and relevant aspect to this research is the role of maternal-fetal attachment, as this is arguably the earliest measurement of parenting quality (13). This concept is derived from Cranley (1981) and includes the desire to know the baby, pleasure related to interactions with the unborn child, and most powerfully, a desire to protect the fetus.…”

Prenatal Attachment and Perinatal Depression: A Systematic Review

“…Many authors underline that low maternal prenatal attachment is associated with low prenatal maternal fetus representations and self-care [25][26][27][28][29] and low postnatal attachment until 24 months postpartum [30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37][38][39]. Additionally, poor parental prenatal attachment has been connected to behavioral and conduct problems, lower cognitive development, and negative socioemotional regulations in early childhood [40][41][42].…”

Assessing community readiness for early intervention programmes to promote social and emotional health in children

“…These programmes include interventions that encourage positive parenting skills or that reduce the risk of perinatal depression . The quality of interactions in the first few years of life can affect a child's life course trajectory well into adulthood . In consequence, early intervention policies and programmes which enable parents to help children achieve the best start in life are promoted as a blueprint for a healthy and happy society…”