Association between Parkinson’s Disease and Cigarette Smoking, Rural Living, Well-Water Consumption, Farming and Pesticide Use: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Abstract

ObjectiveBradford Hill’s viewpoints were used to conduct a weight-of-the-evidence assessment of the association between Parkinson’s disease (PD) and rural living, farming and pesticide use. The results were compared with an assessment based upon meta-analysis. For comparison, we also evaluated the association between PD and cigarette smoking as a “positive control” because a strong inverse association has been described consistently in the literature.MethodsPubMed was searched systematically to identify all published epidemiological studies that evaluated associations between Parkinson’s disease (PD) and cigarette smoking, rural living, well-water consumption, farming and the use of pesticides, herbicides, insecticides, fungicides or paraquat. Studies were categorized into two study quality groups (Tier 1 or Tier 2); data were abstracted and a forest plot of relative risks (RRs) was developed for each risk factor. In addition, when available, RRs were tabulated for more highly exposed individuals compared with the unexposed. Summary RRs for each risk factor were calculated by meta-analysis of Tier 1, Tier 2 and all studies combined, with sensitivity analyses stratified by other study characteristics. Indices of between-study heterogeneity and evidence of reporting bias were assessed. Bradford Hill’s viewpoints were used to determine if a causal relationship between PD and each risk factor was supported by the weight of the evidence.FindingsThere was a consistent inverse (negative) association between current cigarette smoking and PD risk. In contrast, associations between PD and rural living, well-water consumption, farming and the use of pesticides, herbicides, insecticides, fungicides or paraquat were less consistent when assessed quantitatively or qualitatively.ConclusionThe weight of the evidence and meta-analysis support the conclusion that there is a causal relationship between PD risk and cigarette smoking, or some unknown factor correlated with cigarette smoking. There may be risk factors associated with rural living, farming, pesticide use or well-water consumption that are causally related to PD, but the studies to date have not identified such factors. To overcome the limitations of research in this area, future studies will have to better characterize the onset of PD and its relationship to rural living, farming and exposure to pesticides.

Assessment of the Effects of MPTP and Paraquat on Dopaminergic Neurons and Microglia in the Substantia Nigra Pars Compacta of C57BL/6 Mice

“…These results have been reviewed by Mandel et al, [17] in regard to epidemiology studies and Breckenridge et al [18], who conducted a weight of the evidence assessment.…”

La Enfermedad de Parkinson: Etiología, Tratamientos y Factores Preventivos

“…Algunos otros estudios han demostrado una correlación inversa entre el alto consumo de café, el tabaquismo, el consumo de té y la aparición de EP (Liou et al, 1997;Breckenridge, Berry, Chang, Sielken, Jr., & Mandel, 2016). En esta última sección se abordarán los efectos protectores de la nicotina y la cafeína en EP.…”

Development of a Thai Parkinson's Disease Screening Tool and the Prevalence of Parkinsonism and Parkinson's Disease, Based on a Community Survey in Bangkok

“…Several studies demonstrated geographical variations, with a higher prevalence of PD in particular areas, and proposed a link to environmental factors such as pesticides [1]. However, 2 recent meta-analyses highlighted the high heterogeneity and inconsistency among studies [2,3]. Reported differences may be explained by differential healthcare access and a disproportionate distribution of specialist physicians.…”