Assessment of nurses’ respect for patient privacy by patients and nurses: A comparative study

Abstract

Aims To determine whether nurses respect or violate patient privacy by comparing nurses’ and patients’ opinions. Background Although nurses want to respect patient privacy, they can sometimes violate patient privacy or not pay enough attention. Method This comparative and cross‐sectional study was conducted with 357 patients and 305 nurses in 12 public hospitals in Trabzon, Turkey. Data were collected with an information form and the Patient Privacy Scale. Reporting is consistent with the STROBE checklist for cross‐sectional studies. Results The total mean score of the patient privacy scale was 4.6 ± 0.39 for nurses and 4.5 ± 0.41 for patients, and no significant difference was found between their scores (U = 52999.0; p = .554). Further, the nurses (U = 14358.0; p = .000) and the patients (U = 13272.5; p = .006) in the public hospitals had statistically significantly higher overall privacy scores than those in the training and research hospitals. The overall privacy scale scores were higher and more statistically significant in the patients hospitalised in surgical clinics than those hospitalised in clinics for internal diseases (U = 8514.0; p = .005) and in single compared to married patients (U = 12364.5; p = .034). Conclusion Nurses respected patient privacy highly according to both nurses and patients, and there was no significant difference between their views. However, nurses working in training and research hospitals and internal diseases clinics need to improve their approaches to patient privacy. Relevance to clinical practice The results of this study could be used to reduce patient privacy vulnerabilities in complex hospitals and clinics such as training and research hospitals and to improve institutional policies and activities regarding patient privacy. By comparing the results of patients and nurses, the study provided more consistent and accurate data about patient privacy.

Analysis of patients’ privacy and associated factors in the perioperative period

“…A study of patients and healthcare workers in an Indian hospital showed that patients have higher perceptions of privacy than healthcare workers ( 29 ). Therefore, medical and nursing staff should pay attention to the degree of perioperative patients’ physiological and psychological privacy protection when conducting medical-related operations ( 30 ), and improve the quality and level of medical services.…”

Nurses' Moral Sensitivity and Observance of Patient Privacy: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…1 Because of the importance of the issue, many international declarations or regulations and national legislation of many countries have sought to safeguard this right. [2][3][4][5] The International Council of Nurses defines privacy as "Privacy is the principle of non-interference in one's personal matters, information or physical body." 2 The Turkish Nurses Association has stated that privacy and confidentiality are among the ethical principles and responsibilities of nurses.…”

Improving the perception of respect for and the dignity of inpatients: a systematic review

“…51 A Greek study showed that patients had little idea of their rights 52 and nursing has a very important role in disseminating this knowledge and ethical principles, establishing a relationship of respect for patients' rights and privacy. [53][54][55] Intensive care unit patients often have memories of the environment as hostile and stressful, generating negative feelings of violation of their rights to dignity and privacy, lack of empathy, not being understood, delay in getting help and being subject to full control by health professionals. 56 Most patients are unaware of their rights 57 ; a study with the distribution of information cards to patients with methicillin-resistant S. aureus infection, which should be presented to the professionals with whom they would consult, showed that these patients are subject to discrimination and lack of knowledge, which makes its use questionable.…”