Background: Altered central pain mechanisms is a feature of other chronic pain states and upper limb tendinopathies. It is uncertain whether the same applies to chronic Achilles tendinopathy (AT). Objective: To investigate altered central pain mechanisms in chronic AT by assessing conditioned pain modulation (CPM) in recreational athletes with and without chronic AT. Methods: Recreational athletes with chronic AT (ATN) rated their tendinopathy symptoms on the VISA-A, and short forms of the McGill Pain Questionnaire and the Brief Pain Inventory. The CPM effect was triggered in athletes with tendinopathy (ATN, n = 123) and without tendinopathy (CON, n = 100). The cold pressor test was the conditioning stimulus, and pressure pain was the test stimulus. Results: Participants with tendinopathy had lower pressure pain thresholds before (median (IQR) [ATN: 417 (364 − 516) vs CON 601 (459 − 724), P < .01] and during [ATN: 458 (358 − 550) vs CON 633 (506 − 753), P < .01] cold pressor test. No differences were observed for the CPM effect between the two groups (P = .49). Conclusion: There was no difference in the CPM effect between athletes with AT and pain-free controls. Perhaps because tendon pain is a peripheral phenomenon, there are no alterations in descending pain modulation with chronic AT.