Assessing the State of Knowledge Regarding the Effectiveness of Interventions to Contain Pandemic Influenza Transmission: A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis

Abstract

BackgroundInfluenza pandemics occur when a novel influenza strain, to which humans are immunologically naïve, emerges to cause infection and illness on a global scale. Differences in the viral properties of pandemic strains, relative to seasonal ones, can alter the effectiveness of interventions typically implemented to control seasonal influenza burden. As a result, annual control activities may not be sufficient to contain an influenza pandemic.PurposeThis study seeks to inform pandemic policy and planning initiatives by reviewing the effectiveness of previous interventions to reduce pandemic influenza transmission and infection. Results will inform the planning and design of more focused in-depth systematic reviews for specific types of interventions, thus providing the most comprehensive and current understanding of the potential for alternative interventions to mitigate the burden of pandemic influenza.MethodsA systematic review and narrative synthesis of existing systematic reviews and meta-analyses examining intervention effectiveness in containing pandemic influenza transmission was conducted using information collected from five databases (PubMed, Medline, Cochrane, Embase, and Cinahl/EBSCO). Two independent reviewers conducted study screening and quality assessment, extracting data related to intervention impact and effectiveness.Results and DiscussionMost included reviews were of moderate to high quality. Although the degree of statistical heterogeneity precluded meta-analysis, the present systematic review examines the wide variety of interventions that can impact influenza transmission in different ways. While it appears that pandemic influenza vaccination provides significant protection against infection, there was insufficient evidence to conclude that antiviral prophylaxis, seasonal influenza cross-protection, or a range of non-pharmaceutical strategies would provide appreciable protection when implemented in isolation. It is likely that an optimal intervention strategy will employ a combination of interventions in a layered approach, though more research is needed to substantiate this proposition.Trial RegistrationPROSPERO 42016039803

Effectiveness of workplace social distancing measures in reducing influenza transmission: a systematic review

“…This previous review, which was based on 19 articles (five of these articles included workplace closure and two included workplace social distancing), concluded that combination strategies increased the effectiveness of individual strategies. Other systematic reviews that have assessed the effectiveness of interventions in reducing pandemic influenza transmission did not examine workplace social distancing measures [ 50 ].…”

European Pandemic Influenza Preparedness Planning: A Review of National Plans, July 2016

“…32 Influenza pandemics remain the most likely pandemic threat, with very serious health and socioeconomic consequences. 33 The current review takes forward the work on the pandemic plans by describing the gaps, where the lessons learned 14,16,[18][19][20] from the influenza A (H1N1) pandemic in 2009 remain to be included in the plans. We realize that plans are continuously being revised.…”

Repositioning Chloroquine as Ideal Antiviral Prophylactic against COVID-19 - Time is Now

“…Conceptually, massive antiviral prophylaxis might be effective in containing a viral pandemic as in the use of neuraminidase inhibitors against influenza (Saunders-Hastings et al, 2016). A Cochrane Collaboration review found that prophylactic use of antiviral neuraminidase inhibitors reduce the risk of developing influenza (Jefferson et al, 2014).…”

“…Using influenza as a model for preventive management of respiratory viral pandemics, the key concerns are surges in community attack rates and healthcare system demand (Nap et al, 2007) , which in turn lead to disruptions in healthcare with potentially disastrous social and economic ramifications. In their systemic review and meta-analysis of effective interventions to contain an influenza pandemic, Saunders-Hastings et al identified vaccination and antiviral prophylaxis as two major pharmaceutical interventions that can be effective (Saunders-Hastings et al, 2016). However, to date we have neither developed a vaccine nor is there any approved or established antiviral prophylaxis in deployment against In the case of COVID-19, hiding in plain view is a plausible and potential prophylaxis option that can be relatively easily achievable by repositioning the old drug chloroquine (CQ), one of the most prescribed drugs in the world today (White et al, 2014).…”