Assessing the performances of some recently proposed density functionals for the description of organometallic structures

Abstract

International audienceThe performances of a family of recently developed generalized gradient approximation (GGA) functionals based on the Tognetti-Cortona-Adamo (TCA) family and making use of the gradient-regulated connection (GRAC) approach are here tested on an uncommon benchmark set for the prediction of transition state (TS) structures and energies of a series of four reactions involving an early transition metal (Zr, d (0)). This benchmark test thus represents the first step in the organometallic world in which d (n) ions allowing complex phenomena such as spin crossover represent the higher level of complexity. The results obtained show that the performances of the GRAC-xxx functionals are comparable to those of global hybrid functionals both in the prediction of reaction barriers and of structural features of TSs. More complex functional forms (such as range-separated hybrids) in average enhance the energetic features, but not necessarily the overall accuracy on calculated structures. On the other hand, and as expected, purposely developed functionals for the prediction of chemical reactivity provide both structural and energetic features in good agreement with post-HF results. The present study, besides proving the good performances of GGA functionals of the GRAC-TCA family for the prediction of TS structural parameters and energetics of metal containing systems, also underlines the importance of the use of diversified benchmark sets to allow a fair evaluation of functionals performances

Deciphering the Mechanism of Coordinative Chain Transfer Polymerization of Ethylene Using Neodymocene Catalysts and Dialkylmagnesium

“…Considering the complexity of the system and the expected accuracy of the calculations, this value compares well to the computational value of 20.6 kcal mol –1 for a mechanism that involves the heterotrimer NdMg 2 a as a dormant species and (C 5 Me 5 ) 2 LnR as the active complex. In addition, the difference of 3 kcal mol –1 between measured and calculated activation energies corresponds to the best match among the set of functionals tested and fits with the expected precision of this methodology. − In addition, the mechanism is in line with a previously postulated mechanism. , In this mechanism, the active species is ca. 10 kcal mol –1 less stable than the dormant heterobimetallic trimer species.…”

Hyper Open-Shell Excited Spin States of Transition-Metal Compounds: FeF2, FeF2···Ethane, and FeF2···Ethylene

“…Experimental determination of the relative spin-state energies is not always available, especially for large complexes, and for such cases, insights from theoretical calculations can be very helpful. Theoretical calculations using Kohn–Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT) are widely used due to the ability of KS-DFT to model large metal-containing systems at a reasonable computational cost and with reasonable accuracy. − KS-DFT has been widely validated for transition-metal thermochemistry, − especially for properties involving the lowest-energy spin state.…”

Ethylene–Butadiene Copolymerization by Neodymocene Complexes: A Ligand Structure/Activity/Polymer Microstructure Relationship Based on DFT Calculations

“…The calculated values are in excellent agreement with experiment, with our modeling strategy affording relative kinetics parameters within 1 kcal mol –1 of experimental values. This precision is comparable to that attained in state-of-the-art molecular modeling of transition metal reactivity. ,− …”