Aquatic Ecological Risks Posed by Tributyltin in United States Surface Waters: Pre-1989 to 1996 Data

Abstract

Abstract-Acute and chronic risks to aquatic life from exposure to tributyltin (TBT) in surface waters were assessed probabilistically using more than 9 years of monitoring data. More than 50 sites around the United States were sampled, representing six saltwater regions and one freshwater (Lake Erie). Ambient TBT concentrations were compared to acute and chronic effect thresholds to estimate risks for each year (1986-1988 and 1992-1996), site type, and region. Site types comprised commercial harbors, shipyards, marinas, and fish/shellfish habitats proximate to these commercial areas. Tributyltin concentrations in surface waters have declined in all regions and site types since passage of the Organotin Antifouling Paint Control Act in 1988. No risks of acute toxicity have been suggested since 1994. Chronic risks have remained highest in marinas compared to other site types but have declined from a risk involving 25% of the species prior to 1989 to one involving 6% of the species in 1996. Risks associated with commercial harbors and shipyards have been similar (4-6%) since 1994. Chronic risks have been Յ1% in fish and shellfish habitats sampled Ͻ1 to 2 km from TBT sources. Risks in Galveston Bay, over all years (1-19%), have been greater than in the other regions (Յ9%).

Estimating surface water concentrations of “down-the-drain” chemicals in China using a global model

“…This is not unexpected since it is well recognised that even relatively minor and intermittent untreated discharge can exert a dominant influence on pollutant concentrations in receiving systems (see Whelan et al, 1999). Derivation of a statistical distribution of PECs allows probabilistic risk (sensu Cardwell et al, 1999) to quantified by integrating the product of the exposure probability density function (essentially the relative frequency distribution of PECs) and the species sensitivity distribution (representing the effect vs concentration relationship). That said, the extent to which conventional risk assessment for "down-the-drain" chemicals is a useful indicator of ecological impact is questionable in systems receiving significant volumes of untreated waste water (direct discharge) because the ecosystem is often so impacted by high concentrations of sanitary determinands, such as BOD, ammonia and nitrite Finnegan et al, 2009) In the scenario in which 100% provision of secondary sewage treatment was assumed, surface water exposure to LAS is significantly reduced (Figure 2b).…”

Assessing acute and chronic copper risks to freshwater aquatic life using species sensitivity distributions for different taxonomic groups

“…Potential risk can be expressed as a probability distribution rather than a single value. Parkhurst et al [3] developed a methodology for conducting probabilistic aquatic life risk assessments, and several others have published probabilistic risk assessments using similar methods [4–6].…”

Efficiency of sediment quality guidelines for predicting toxicity: The case of the St. Lawrence river

“…However, in this area, high concentrations of organotin contaminants, such as tributyltin (TBT), were observed by Pelletier (2008). Because organotins have been historically considered as a problem in marine environments (Cardwell et al 1999), their impacts on freshwater ecosystems should not be overlooked. Organotins are persistent in sediments, and benthic invertebrates may be directly exposed to them as they ingest and burrow into sediments (Bartlett et al 2004).…”