Appropriating Information Technology Artefacts through Trial and Error: The Case of the Tablet

Abstract

The concept of appropriation is of paramount importance for the lasting use of an Information Technology (IT) artefact following its initial adoption, and therefore its success. However, quite often, users' original expectations are negatively disconfirmed, and instead of appropriating the IT artefact, they discontinue its use. In this study we examine the use of IT artefacts following negative disconfirmation and use Grounded Theory Method techniques to analyse 136 blogposts, collected between March 2011-July 2017, to investigate how users appropriate or reject the tablet when technology falls short of users' expectations. Our findings show that users overcome negative disconfirmation through a trial and error process. In doing so, we identify that users appropriate the tablet when the attained benefits significantly outweigh the risks or sacrifices stemming out of its use. We discuss our contribution within the context of the appropriation literature, and highlight that the success of IT lies with the user's success in identifying personal use scenarios within and across diverse contexts of use.

A Confirmation Bias View on Social Media Induced Polarisation During Covid-19

“…Drawing on contemporary literature, we frame the theoretical and empirical contributions of this study (Ågerfalk, 2014;Corley & Gioia, 2011;Zamani et al, 2020). This is attained in several ways.…”

“…Manifestations of SMIP include misinformation about presidential election campaigns (Guess et al, 2018 ; Linvill & Warren, 2020 ; Schäfer et al, 2017 ), race (Jamieson, 2020 ), immigration (Jaramillo-Dent & Pérez-Rodríguez, 2021 ; Newman et al, 2017 ), religion (Said, 2008 ), and pandemics, specifically Covid-19 (Laato et al, 2020 ). The rapid global adoption of social media technology has significantly influenced many job roles and supply chain activities (Ribarsky et al, 2014 ; Zamani et al, 2020 ). Organisations are incorporating social media technology as a core capability to deliver information efficiently and cost-effectively to stakeholders in their supply chain (Osatuyi, 2013 ; Thatcher et al, 2018 ; Xie & Lee, 2015 ; Zhang et al, 2017 ).…”

Generative mechanisms of workarounds, discontinuance and reframing: a study of negative disconfirmation with consumerised IT

“…Contrary to discontinuance behavioural outcomes, the breadth of adaptations, be it workarounds, revisions or other modifications at task‐, technology‐ or user‐level, indicate a willingness to make IT work (Zamani & Pouloudi, 2019; Zamani, Pouloudi, Giaglis, & Wareham, 2020) and overcome the discrepancies that obstruct the user from completing their tasks; as such they signal continuance rather than discontinuance intentions (Barrett, 2018; Wu et al, 2017) and possibly indicate the user's intention to appropriate the device (Zamani et al, 2020).…”

Antecedents of Digital Platform Organising Visions

“…Digital innovation diffusion is of great interest in the IS scholarship [1]- [4], [14], [15]. Scholars seek to understand why and how some innovations are widely adopted while others do not succeed.…”

“…Information Systems (IS) scholars have a long concern to understand the reasons that drive a wide diffusion of some digital innovations while others fail [1]- [4]. A number of writers have followed the rational-economic perspective [5], paying attention to how organisations assess properties and performance of technologies to understand digital innovation diffusion and its relation to value generation.…”