Applying the Challenge-Hindrance Stressor Framework to Doctoral Education

Abstract

<jats:p> Doctoral education is inherently stressful for students. While the implications of stress on employees has been heavily investigated within the management literature, what we know about stress has not yet been applied to doctoral education. We take initial steps toward using the stress literature to examine stress in doctoral education by applying the challenge-hindrance stressor framework to the doctoral education context. We briefly define both challenge and hindrance stressors and list common stressors for both related to prototypical learning experiences in doctoral education. Next, we point out that student responses to stress vary because of individual differences, influencing the extent to which students appraise stressors as more hindrance or challenge focused. We also provide rich examples of learning experiences within doctoral education that demonstrate how these experiences incorporate hindrance and challenge stressors. Through these examples, we illustrate how educators can design major learning experiences in doctoral education to address (or at least minimize) hindrance stressors and integrate more challenge stressors. Last, we provide theory-driven recommendations for doctoral educators to capitalize on the positive effects of challenge stressors, and we discuss ways to establish a future research agenda to empirically test the challenge-hindrance framework in the doctoral education context. </jats:p>

Examining the Practices and Challenges of Distance Education of PhD Candidates in the Context of COVID-19

“…Training of PhD candidates is difficult and stressful for postgraduate students (McCauley & Hinojosa, 2020) and is different from the training of undergraduate or graduate students. Postgraduate students have a significant psycho-emotional stress, so it is recommended to overcome it through the implementation of health and recreational technologies (Bugaychuk, 2015).…”

Using Group Messaging to Facilitate Peer Support Among Early Doctoral Students: A Thematic Analysis of One Cohort’s Text Messages

“…Students in this study clearly experienced a great deal of anxiety over coursework. While academic stress that positively challenges students leads to personal growth (McCauley & Hinojosa, 2020), for academic stress to be productive, students need to understand it as a normal part of the graduate school experience. To attain that understanding, students need space outside the view of their faculty to share these challenges with peers (Barreira et al, 2018;Hockey, 1994).…”

An Empirical Investigation of Mental Illness, Impostor Syndrome, and Social Support in Management Doctoral Programs

“…A recent study by the American College Health Association (ACHA) found that over 92% of graduate students reported having average to “tremendous” stress over the prior year (ACHA, 2017). Indeed, high levels of coursework in some programs combined with time pressure, social isolation, and low levels of support typically means that “doctoral education is inherently stressful for students” (McCauley & Hinojosa, 2020, p. 490). Furthermore, chronic stress is a known contributor to mental illness.…”