Applying an Electronic Health Records Data Quality Framework Across Service Sectors: A Case Study of Juvenile Justice System Data

Abstract

Context: Integrating electronic health records (EHR) with other sources of administrative data is key to identifying factors affecting the long-term health of traditionally underserved populations, such as individuals involved in the justice system. Linking existing administrative data from multiple sources overcomes many of the limitations of traditional prospective studies of population health, but the linking process assumes high levels of data quality and consistency within administrative data. Studies of EHR, unlike other types of administrative data, have provided guidance to evaluate the utility of big data for population health research. Case Description: Here, an established EHR data quality framework was applied to identify and describe the potential shortcomings of administrative juvenile justice system data collected by one of four case management systems (CMSs) across 12 counties in a Midwest state. The CMS data were reviewed for logical inconsistencies and compared along the data quality dimensions of plausibility and completeness. Major Themes: After applying the data quality framework, several patterns of logical inconsistencies within the data were identified. To resolve these inconsistencies, recommendations regarding data entry, review, and extraction are offered. Conclusion: The recommendations related to achieving quality justice system data can be applied to future efforts to link administrative databases from multiple sources. Increasing trust in administrative data quality related to vulnerable populations ultimately improves knowledge of pressing public health concerns.

Computer System for the Capture and Preparation of Cytopathological Reports for Cervical Cancer Detection and His Utility in Training for Health Personnel

“…Some authors point out that erroneous or incomplete data is produced by socio-cultural barriers between health personnel and users of health services [ 30 ]. Therefore, this variability in the completeness of the data is not attributed to the system since the DCS-TDCC has mandatory fields and fields with predefined data for registration, which facilitates the process of communication and interoperability [ 31 , 32 ], and thus avoids that there are imprecise diagnoses with false positives or false negatives in the interpretation of cervical cytology by the pathologist [ 18 , 33 ].…”

Patterns of drug screen results and court-ordered substance use treatment referrals and completion among justice-involved youth

“…Details regarding type of treatment (e.g., modality, duration) and treatment quality-which could influence treatment engagement-were also missing. These limitations more broadly highlight issues with administrative data, and in this case court records, which are often subject to error (Aalsma et al, 2019) and not always a reliable source of information regarding treatment or service utilization (Dennis et al, 2019;Scott et al, 2019). Last, the article focused on how the court responds to positive ODS results; additional research should examine differences in judicial decision-making among youth with and without history of positive ODS.…”

The point of diminishing returns in juvenile probation: Probation requirements and risk of technical probation violations among first-time probation-involved youth.

“…Third, we rely on administrative data, in which data quality is often a concern. Still, we utilized sophisticated data management and cleaning to ensure data quality (Aalsma, Schwartz, Haight, Jarjoura, & Dir, 2019). Lastly, we are unable to account for the probation officer's perspective and judgment during the decision-making process.…”