Application of Cost-Benefit Analysis to the Health Services and the Special Case of Technologic Innovation

Abstract

As an economic technique for evaluating specific projects or programs in the public sector, cost-benefit analysis is relatively new. In this paper, the theory and practice of cost-benefit analysis in general are discussed as a basis for considering its role in assessing technology in the health services. A review of the literature on applications of cost-benefit or cost-effectiveness analysis to the health field reveals that few complete studies have been conducted to date. It is suggested that an adequate analysis requires an empirical approach in which costs and benefits are juxtaposed, and in which presumed benefits reflect an ascertained relationship between inputs and outputs. A threefold classification of benefits is commonly employed: direct, indirect, and intangible. Since the latter pose difficulty, cost-effectiveness analysis is often the more practicable procedure. After summarizing some problems in predicting how technologic developments are likely to affect costs and benefits, the method of cost-benefit analysis is applied to developments of health systems technology in two settings-the hospital and automated multiphasic screening. These examples underscore the importance of solving problems of measurement and valuation of a project or program in its concrete setting. Finally, barriers to the performance of sound and systematic analysis are listed, and the political context of decision making in the public sector is emphasized.

A Theory of Constraints Approach to Health Technology Assessment

“…Financial evaluation methodology has been widely discussed in the literature (e.g. [11][12][13][14][15] The proposed matrix, as many other similar decisionmaking tools (e.g. Quality Function Deployment (QFD) [16], etc…) can be used at various levels of detail and sophistication.…”

Avaliação da qualidade dos serviços de saúde: notas bibliográficas

“…Mas é com a publicação em 1972 de "Effectiveness and Efficiency: Randam Reflections on Health Services" de Cochrane (6) que há um profundo impacto no crescimento dos estudos de CBA/ CEA voltados para a avaliação dos serviços de saúde. Entre os trabalhos podemos destacar os dois artigos publicados em 1974 por Klauman (19), com a metodologia e aplicações do CBA,e os publicados por Weinstein (30), três anos após, com a discussão da metodologia e aplicações da CEA. A partir de então há um aumento acentuado de estudos de CBA/CEA na avaliação de serviços de saúde.…”

Cadmium Exposure in Daye County, China: Environmental Assessment and Management, Health and Economic Effects

“…the economic costs saved by such control, as for example applied by Karlman [7] and by Weisbrod [8,9] and as discussed by Butler and Doessel [10]. Drummond et al, [11, p. 149] refer to the method used here as the market valuation method of assessing costs, in that it takes account of actual valuations where these exist or imputes them by reference to the market price of similar commodities.…”