In patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), a high inspiratory respiratory activity intensity ("drive") leads to a high transpulmonary inspiratory pressure (1), vascular leakage, tachypnea, a high tidal volume (hyperpnea), hypocapnia (2), and pendelluft (3), that is, self-inflicted lung injury (SILI). More severe lung injury leads to a higher drive (4) and vice versa. Therefore, endotracheal intubation ("intubation"), controlled mechanical ventilation and paralysis (i.e., controlled mandatory ventilation [CMV]) are required to interrupt SILI and protect the lung and diaphragm (1-3). Initially, deep sedation, in fact general anesthesia (GA), is needed. However, the respiratory muscles of ARDS patients are fully functional, at variance with exhaustion observed in decompensated chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Thus, CO 2 excretion is not an issue and does require neither resting and paralyzing the muscles nor GA. Hence, our approach to treatment of early severe diffuse ARDS is at variance with present practice (5, 6) but rests on physiologically controlling the drive, allowing for early spontaneous breathing (SB) (7-9). Indeed, randomized controlled trials of neuromuscular blockade (5) are flawed (10), as there is no comparison with adequate SB. Furthermore, the duration of paralysis is undocumented: 12 hours (11), 24 hours, or 48 hours (5)? Similarly, the randomized controlled trials of prone positioning ("proning") ( 6) are not compared with upright positioning (12) despite a similar increase in Pao 2 /Fio 2 (P/F). Finally, is prolonged GA harmful or beneficial to the patients? Are these questions relevant? Indeed, the use of CMV + GA + paralysis + proning decreased mortality from ~45-52% (13) to 16% (6) (Milan: 15-20%, J. J. Marini, personal communication, 2020). However, mortality remained high in some critical care units (CCUs) at the beginning of the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (coronavirus disease [COVID]) pandemic (mortality: 88% [14]; Lombardy excluding Milan: ∼80%). We will provide some thoughts below which we argue that CMV + GA + paralysis + proning is only a rescue therapy but is currently being used as first-line therapy. This style of practice does not address: a) the shortage of proning staff and anesthetics and the required high turnover, b) the core disease including early expiratory bronchiolar (11) or alveolar closure ("closure"; diffuse alveolar disease) that lowers the oxygen diffusion surface,