Anticipating surprise: the case of the early warning system of Rijkswaterstaat in the Netherlands

Abstract

Policy often has to perform amidst uncertain and rapidly changing conditions. Robustness is the ability to perform and achieve intended effects under unknown conditions. Robust design can benefit from the capacity to anticipate developments early. A system of early warning is a method to anticipate change early and help policy design to be more robust. Early warning can enable moment of 'consecration', moments where reflection on assumptions and biased of policy design can be challenged and changed; this can be an important addition to the robustness of policy design. However, early warning is not unproblematic; it is an organizational practice that inherently invokes issues of habituation, organizational bias, as it challenges the status quo. In this paper, we study how policy makers who 'do' early warning in the context of robust policy engage with these issues and how they managed to improve the robustness of policy design. We do so by studying an empirical case of an early warning system in The Netherlands. We analyze how the system was build, how it worked, how it was further professionalized, and what the system did to the capacity of the organization to design and deliver robust policy.

Sustainable Mobilities in the Neighborhood: Methodological Innovation for Social Change

“…At the level of everyday life, new mobility potentials can be tapped and citizens can actively develop the future of mobility and become co-producers or "prosumers" of mobility solutions as needed. In this way, innovative solutions are often generated spontaneously by committed citizens or organizations because they see an opportunity or because they simply feel the necessity to act [16].…”

Combining Deep Learning and Location-Based Ranking for Large-Scale Archaeological Prospection of LiDAR Data from The Netherlands

“…The LiDAR data were commissioned by the Dutch Directorate-General for Public Works and Water Management and collected by helicopter with a Riegl LMS-Q680i scanner in April 2010. The data were classified into non-ground and ground points and interpolated, resulting in a digital terrain model (ground points) with an average point density of 6-10 per m 2 , a spatial resolution of 50 cm, and a vertical and planimetric accuracy of 5 cm [42]. The data are disseminated in GeoTIFF tiles measuring 10,000 by 12,500 pixels (5 km by 6.25 km).…”

Policy capacities and effective policy design: a review

“…Robustness over time can enable policymakers, organizations or a system to endure shocks, policy surprises, and turbulence, while allowing them flexibility (Ansell et al, 2016 ; Capano & Woo, 2017 ; Howlett et al, 2018 ; Mergel et al, 2021 ). Endurance could be achieved with adaptability to structural, institutional and actor-level changes and/or evolution of existing policy capacities over time (e.g., Alaerts, 2020 ; Capano & Pavan, 2019 ; Van Der Steen et al, 2018 ). And subsequent adaptability could arise on improvements in complementarities among different types and levels of critical capacity requisites.…”