Androgenic Morality? Associations of sex, oral contraceptive use and basal testosterone levels with moral decision making

Abstract

Since previous studies have reported stronger utilitarian tendencies in men, the relationship between testosterone and moral judgments has gained interest. Utilitarian judgements focus on the consequences of actions in terms of a cost-benefit analysis while deontological judgements are based on rules that are independent of an action’s outcome or of situational features. We investigated decisions in moral dilemma situations in N = 157 young adults using a process dissociation approach to allow an independent estimate of underlying utilitarianism and deontology. Significant effects of sex (p = .009) and use of oral contraceptives (p = .011) on utilitarianism were found with the highest levels in men and the lowest in free cycling women while oral contraceptive users fell in between. Furthermore, there were correlations of salivary testosterone with utilitarianism in free cycling women (r = .303) and with deontology in men (r = -.263) while no significant associations between testosterone and moral choices were found in oral contraceptive users. The findings underscore the role of testosterone in moral judgements but also point to specific associations depending on sex and oral contraceptive use.

Moralische Kompetenz bei Medizinstudierenden – Vergleich zwischen Studierenden des ersten Semesters und des Praktischen Jahres

“…Diese zeigen, dass man Testosteron in Verbindung mit einer verminderten Empfindlichkeit gegenüber affektiven emotionalen Entscheidungen bringen kann [11,12]. Höhere Serumlevel von Testosteron seien demnach mit verminderter Empathie und auf neurobiologischer Ebene mit einer verminderten Aktivität des ventromedialen präfrontalen Kortex verknüpft [13,14]. Ein überdurchschnittlicher Testosteronwert scheint demnach mit einer eher utilitaristischen Bewertung moralischer Dilemmata zu korrelieren [15].…”