Analysis of questioning technique during classes in medical education

Abstract

BackgroundQuestioning is one of the essential techniques used by lecturers to make lectures more interactive and effective. This study surveyed the perception of questioning techniques by medical school faculty members and analyzed how the questioning technique is used in actual classes.MethodsData on the perceptions of the questioning skills used during lectures was collected using a self‒questionnaire for faculty members (N = 33) during the second semester of 2008. The questionnaire consisted of 18 items covering the awareness and characteristics of questioning skills. Recorded video tapes were used to observe the faculty members’ questioning skills.ResultsMost faculty members regarded the questioning technique during classes as being important and expected positive outcomes in terms of the students’ participation in class, concentration in class and understanding of the class contents. In the 99 classes analyzed, the median number of questions per class was 1 (0–29). Among them, 40 classes (40.4 %) did not use questioning techniques. The frequency of questioning per lecture was similar regardless of the faculty members’ perception. On the other hand, the faculty members perceived that their usual wait time after question was approximately 10 seconds compared to only 2.5 seconds measured from video analysis. More lecture‒experienced faculty members tended to ask more questions in class.ConclusionsThere were some discrepancies regarding the questioning technique between the faculty members’ perceptions and reality, even though they had positive opinions of the technique. The questioning skills during a lecture need to be emphasized to faculty members.

Actual preoperative fasting time in Brazilian hospitals: the BIGFAST multicenter study

“… 17 Some studies have clearly shown that what we think we are doing is far from what is really happening, due to a wrong perception of reality. 18 , 19 Awareness of a perception– reality gap in medical care is important when providing continuing medical education and may significantly alter behavior in beneficial ways for patient care. 20 The perceived period of preoperative fasting among patients undergoing surgery is hardly known.…”

Using Testing as a Learning Tool

“…If, for example, a question is posed and an instructor calls on the first person who raises their hand to answer, many students in the class will not have had time to generate a response, functionally rendering the questioning more of a "study" event than a "test" event. Thus, one simple but powerful suggestion for implementing whole-class questioning as opportunities to generate a testing effect include waiting a sufficient amount of time for a response (at least 3 to 5 seconds 29,30 ) to increase the chance that other students will have time to practice retrieval. Of course, even with extended wait time, not all students will engage in retrieval when a question is posed to a large class.…”

Medical Students Perception to Different Types of Reasoning Questions in Histology Lectures

“…Even though the utility of questioning in enhancing learning has been well documented, the time allotted for questioning in teaching and learning sessions is often negligible. 9,15 In the present study, specific questions were deliberately incorporated into the instructional design of histology lecture classes and considerable time devoted to them during the sessions to enhance learner engagement. Another common pitfall is the over-utilization of questions that require only factual recall to answer them.…”