Analysis of interpretive structural model of Indian railway security system by analytic hierarchy process (AHP)

Abstract

Purpose Security and safety have remained important concerns for mankind since ancient times. In the context of railways, however, the threat perceptions to safety and security have increased significantly lately. In view of this, the Indian Railways requires an effective and efficient security management system. The purpose of this paper is to propose an integrated approach to help develop the Indian railway security system (IRSS) by successively reducing the complexity of the system through a series of studies. Design/methodology/approach The relevant elements of the complex system of Indian Railways have been identified. The framework in which the elements exist and interact with each other has been clearly established using the interpretive structural modelling (ISM) technique. The output of ISM is further reduced in complexity by having different policy option profiles. A comparison of different option profiles has been done by a multi-criteria decision-making technique, the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), by choosing suitable criteria for comparison. Findings The following elements need to be pursued as the key objectives for making IRSS: protection of passengers, protection of property, modernisation, manpower enhancement, multi-skilling of staff, latest technology and enhanced legal powers. Research limitations/implications The present research can be extended in many important ways. Interpretive structural models for different contextual relationships can be developed and used for formulating and implementing customised security policy. Policy elements and the ISM structure obtained in this research can be utilised for the system dynamic modelling of IRSS. A pilot study can be done to implement the recommendations made in this study. Practical implications The ISM model developed can be implemented as a policy tool in enhancing the railway’s security. Some of the policy elements proposed appear to be consistent with the strategic direction being undertaken in the railway security in the country. Social implications Security is an important concern for mankind and social civilisations. The results have significant welfare implications in India and the rest of the world. Originality/value The present study is one of the first approaches in a series of studies in railway security in India. The results of this study can be extended to other security scenarios with similar needs.

Research on Comprehensive Evaluation of Economic Management Performance Based on Improved Fuzzy Clustering Algorithm

“…Due to the subjective influence of the evaluator in the measurement process, it is difficult to reach an agreement. In such cases, consistency test can be carried out according to the principle of the specific formula of the matrix to ensure that the judgment results are relatively consistent on the whole [18]:…”

Analysis of challenges for automobile service garages in India: a structural modeling approach

“…The ISM methodology had been successfully used by several researchers for modeling similar research objectives that include analysis of interactions among the barriers of reverse logistics (Ravi and Shankar, 2005), modeling of knowledge management barriers (Singh and Kant, 2008), modeling of factors for improving competitiveness of SMEs (Rajesh et al , 2007), analysis of inhibitors of service supply chain (Pramod and Banwet, 2010), modeling of critical success factors of blockchain based cloud services (Prasad et al , 2018), modeling of Indian railway security system (Srivastava et al , 2019), etc.…”

Benefits of Goods and Services Tax implementation in India: An analytical hierarchy process approach

“…The respondents ranked each parameters on the 9 point scale as suggested by Saaty (1980) given in Table 2. This is the most robust method designed to know the reflection of people related to various policies of government (Bahurmoz, Mukhtar, & Al-Sharqi, 2015;Pazil, Muhammad, Othman, & Abdullah, 2019;Srivastava, Gaur, Swami, & Banwet, 2019). It has been used in this study to compare and prioritize various benefits of GST implementation.…”

“…AHP technique has been used in this study since it is one of the most widely used and preferred methods for multi‐criteria decision making in public related affairs (Bayazit, 2005; Kahraman, Demirel, & Demirel, 2007; Kumar & Gupta, 2020; Yoon, Kim, & Park, 2020; Lee & Chan, 2008). This is the most robust method designed to know the reflection of people related to various policies of government (Bahurmoz, Mukhtar, & Al‐Sharqi, 2015; Pazil, Muhammad, Othman, & Abdullah, 2019; Srivastava, Gaur, Swami, & Banwet, 2019). It has been used in this study to compare and prioritize various benefits of GST implementation.…”