Analysing the hidden curriculum: use of a cultural web

Abstract

CONTEXT Major influences on learning about medical professionalism come from the hidden curriculum. These influences can contribute positively or negatively towards the professional enculturation of clinical students. The fact that there is no validated method for identifying the components of the hidden curriculum poses problems for educators considering professionalism. The aim of this study was to analyse whether a cultural web, adapted from a business context, might assist in the identification of elements of the hidden curriculum at a UK veterinary school.METHODS A qualitative approach was used. Seven focus groups consisting of three staff groups and four student groups were organised. Questioning was framed using the cultural web, which is a model used by business owners to assess their environment and consider how it affects their employees and customers. The focus group discussions were recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically using a combination of a priori and emergent themes.RESULTS The cultural web identified elements of the hidden curriculum for both students and staff. These included: core assumptions; routines; rituals; control systems; organisational factors; power structures, and symbols. Discussions occurred about how and where these issues may affect students’ professional identity development.CONCLUSIONS The cultural web framework functioned well to help participants identify elements of the hidden curriculum. These aspects aligned broadly with previously described factors such as role models and institutional slang. The influence of these issues on a student’s development of a professional identity requires discussion amongst faculty staff, and could be used to develop learning opportunities for students. The framework is promising for the analysis of the hidden curriculum and could be developed as an instrument for implementation in other clinical teaching environments.

Power distance and migrant nurses: The liminality of acculturation

“…Data analysis highlights not only were they engaging with explicit, formal content, they were also navigating the ‘hidden curriculum’ of an unfamiliar set of beliefs and values about what it means to be a learner. This concept of the hidden curriculum refers to the often tacit or unarticulated assumptions, beliefs and values within organisational structures that maintain existing norms (Hunter & Cook, ; Mossop, Dennick, Hammond, & Robbé, ). This is an important tension to note, as notions of empowerment underpin adult learning theories, but the shift to the inherent low power distance of these approaches can disempower learners if they are not adequately supported through this transition.…”

Twelve tips for applying change models to curriculum design, development and delivery

“…Johnson and Scholes (2009) describe the 'cultural web' which has at its centre 'the paradigm' (in this case the curriculum and its values). Around this lie control systems; organisational structures (the more formal elements of the culture) and power structures (which can be overt or hidden) and the stories, rituals and routines and symbols that represent the curriculum or organisation (Mossop et al 2013). Schein (2010) suggests such 'artefacts' are underpinned by 'espoused values': conscious goals, strategies and philosophies that are easy to see, but often hard to understand.…”

Organizational Change, Leadership, and the Transformation of Continuing Professional Development: Lessons Learned From the American College of Cardiology

“…Members and committees were closely involved in planning and implementing the proposed changes. Focused workgroups were used to promote teamwork and to improve performance . A systematic review of this process found that staff development programs increase participants’ commitment to the institution's mission while increasing confidence, motivation, and awareness of personal strengths and limitations.…”

“…Focused workgroups were used to promote teamwork and to improve performance. 22 A systematic review of this process found that staff development programs increase participants' commitment to the institution's mission while increasing confidence, motivation, and awareness of personal strengths and limitations. In addition to changing leadership styles, development programs encouraged the application of new skills in the workplace, such as departmental reorganization and team building, adoption of new leadership roles and responsibilities, and creation of new collaborations and networks.…”