An updated review of clinical methods in the assessment of ageing skin – New perspectives and evaluation for claims support

Abstract

With the advancement of skin research, today's consumer has increased access to an informed understanding of ageing skin and its appendages, together with a plethora of targeted products to meet such needs. In recent years, increased legislative demands for quality evidential claims support have led not only to the development and validation of clinical methods to measure and quantify ageing skin, but also a clearer understanding of the skin ageing process-especially the impact of both its internal and external environments-as well as a tougher stance on clearly unjustifiable claims. Traditional testing methods used to research and evaluate anti-ageing products claim to employ sophisticated instruments. Today, however, since the term anti-ageing can be considered a misnomer, intelligent use of combined more advanced clinical methods has enabled the development of technologically improved consumer products providing enhanced efficacy and targeted performance. Non-invasive methods for the assessment and quantification of the causes of ageing skin provide tools to the clinical researcher as defined by key clinically observed ageing parameters. Where evidence requires additional support, a number of clinical procedures evaluating ageing skin and hair products are combined with invasive procedures, thus enabling an added value to product claims. As discussed herein, given the enhanced understanding of ageing, we provide an update to our previous reviews of clinical methods used in the assessment of skin ageing, to include the wider aspects of environmental exposure; skin pigmentation; microbiome disturbance; surface topography; colour, radiance, and pH; and structural integrity-all requiring a disciplined approach to their use in dermatological investigations and product claims evidence.

Defining Skin Quality: Clinical Relevance, Terminology, and Assessment

“… 9 Redness (erythema) relates to underlying skin color and relative vascular burden and visibility through the skin. 17 , 66 , 67 Dullness and sallowness refer to the lack of natural radiance and may be associated with a yellow undertone to the skin. These are additional visual signs of poor skin quality, which may result from myriad causes.…”

Mimicking cigarette smoke exposure to assess cutaneous toxicity

“…However, this controlled clinical method also generates a pollution stress on 'living skin'. 36 Ex vivo skin tissue Ex vivo human skin is usually obtained from plastic surgeries either directly from hospitals or distributed by tissue banks. For dermal absorption studies, skin explant is the preferred model since the barrier properties are well preserved after excision with controlled conditions.…”

<p>The Interaction of Age and Anatomical Region Influenced Skin Biophysical Characteristics of Chinese Women</p>

“…Ageing is an inevitable physiology process of humans over time, and both genetic mechanisms and environmental factors can account for it. 1 Skin constitutes the outermost protective barrier which makes it subject to sunlight, air pollution and climate change. All these external factors accelerate the ageing signs of the skin, especially the ultraviolet (UV) radiation-induced photoageing.…”