An ‘In the Wild’ Experiment on Presence and Embodiment using Consumer Virtual Reality Equipment

Abstract

Consumer virtual reality systems are now becoming widely available. We report on a study on presence and embodiment within virtual reality that was conducted 'in the wild', in that data was collected from devices owned by consumers in uncontrolled settings, not in a traditional laboratory setting. Users of Samsung Gear VR and Google Cardboard devices were invited by web pages and email invitation to download and run an app that presented a scenario where the participant would sit in a bar watching a singer. Each participant saw one of eight variations of the scenario: with or without a self-avatar; singer inviting the participant to tap along or not; singer looking at the participant or not. Despite the uncontrolled situation of the experiment, results from an in-app questionnaire showed tentative evidence that a self-avatar had a positive effect on self-report of presence and embodiment, and that the singer inviting the participant to tap along had a negative effect on self-report of embodiment. We discuss the limitations of the study and the platforms, and the potential for future open virtual reality experiments.

Learning Empathy Through Virtual Reality: Multiple Strategies for Training Empathy-Related Abilities Using Body Ownership Illusions in Embodied Virtual Reality

“…Being in the first-person perspective of an avatar that moves in synchronicity with the user may help participants to overcome cognitive loads increasing their memory performance after the VR experience (Steed et al, 2017). Tentative evidence of the positive effect in embodiment and presence of having the first-person perspective of an avatar have also been observed in experiments in uncontrolled settings conducted remotely through an APP through the Internet (Steed et al, 2016). Having an avatar also places participants into the center of the experience (de la Peña et al, 2010).…”

Users’ Perceptions Using Low-End and High-End Mobile-Rendered HMDs: A Comparative Study

“…Larger samples could be collected using this mode of data collection. Steed et al [9] demonstrated the feasibility of running studies on VR using MR HMDs in the wild.…”

“…Steed et al [9] used Samsung Gear VR and Google Cardboard in a study about presence and embodiment within VR in uncontrolled settings. The users of these two MR HMDs were invited to download and run an app that presented a scenario where the participant would sit in a bar watching a singer.…”

Sketch‐based shape‐constrained fireworks simulation in head‐mounted virtual reality

“…In the recent related work, Zhao et al presented a fireworks controller to simulate shape‐constrained fireworks in real time. With the popularity of consumer‐grade virtual reality (VR) devices, especially helmet‐mounted display (HMD) devices, ordinary users are affordable to experience the highly immersive experience of watching virtual fireworks at home. However, Zhao et al's method has the following limitations when used in HMD virtual environments.…”