An Environmental and Operational Analysis of Quality Function Deployment-Based Methods

Abstract

Ecodesign consists of integrating environmental considerations into the product development process by means of practices that involve the use of methods, techniques, tools, and guidelines. However, many published practices do not incorporate important environmental issues, often resulting in a product development process that is ineffective from an ecodesign standpoint. This paper’s aim is threefold: (i) Identifying environmental and operational criteria and determining weights to these criteria; (ii) assessing and selecting quality function deployment (QFD)-based ecodesign methods using environmental and operational criteria, and (iii) analyzing the practitioners’ perception of the most suitable QFD-based method identified by the second aim. To that end, a comprehensive literature review of ecodesign practices based on QFD and its requirements was carried out, and a survey was conducted with environmental science and product development experts, whose answers enabled the prioritization of the characteristics those practices must meet from environmental and operational standpoints. Thereafter, a workshop was carried out with design engineers from an automotive company in Brazil. This study’s findings indicate that many QFD-based ecodesign methods fail to consider the life cycle perspective, do not assess environmental impacts, and have not been tested before being published. Another finding from industry designers suggests that ecodesign methods should be easy to use and not time-consuming.

Importance Level Analysis of Pick-up Schedule for Merchant PT XYZ using QFD

“…There are 3 methods for deciding the degree of significance, to be specific outright significance, relative significance and ordinal significance [6]. a.…”

An Extenics-Based Scheduled Configuration Methodology for Low-Carbon Product Design in Consideration of Contradictory Problem Solving

“…The purpose of the QFD method is to transform design needs into structural modules, and thus to improve product quality. By incorporating environmental aspects of a product into QFD as new design needs, a new set of eco-design tools have been generated, such as green QFD [35], QFD for the environment [36,37]. At an earlier time, Zhang et al [35] proposed the green QFD method for product development or improvement, where the quality house, green house, and cost house are constructed to evaluate the product quality, environmental impacts, and cost of the design scheme, respectively.…”

Sustainable Circular Micro Index for Evaluating Virtual Substitution Using Machine Learning with the Path Planning Problem as a Case Study

“…The frequency of words offers a level of consideration to assess each factor represented by the linguistic value. Thus, the experts are the following approaches: Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) [42], Eco design [43], Eco-innovation [44], Eco-QFD [45] and Eco-efficiency [46]. The following procedure describes the analysis performed to identify and rank the factors considered to contribute to the evaluation of the proposed index.…”