An empirical study of performance measurement in manufacturing firms

Abstract

PurposeThe recent performance measurement literature suggests that organizations should put more emphasis on non‐financial measures in their performance measurement systems, that organizations must use new performance measurement approaches such as the balanced scorecard and that measures should be aligned with contextual factors such as strategy and organizational structure. The purpose of this paper is to assess the extent to which organizations are following these prescriptions.Design/methodology/approachA survey of a sample of Canadian manufacturing firms was conducted. In the questionnaire, organizations had to indicate the extent to which they use 73 performance measures. They also had to respond to questions about determinants such as strategy, organizational structure and environmental uncertainty. More than 100 organizations responded to the survey. The response rate was 50.5 percent.FindingsThe results show that manufacturing firms continue to use financial performance measures. Despite the recommendations from experts and academics, the proportion of firms that implement a balanced scorecard or integrated performance measurement systems is low. Furthermore, organizations that use these approaches are not employing more extensively non‐financial measures than those which are applying traditional performance measurement approaches. This research project also shows that there are some significant relationships between the types of measures and contextual factors like strategy, decentralization and environmental uncertainty. This research finally demonstrates clearly that there is a need to develop a theory that explains how firms can use their performance measurement system to enhance their performance.Originality/valueThis paper provides information on performance measures used by organizations and their association with organizational determinants.

Business Performance Measurements in Asset Management with the Support of Big Data Technologies

“…Olve et al [8] emphasized on the need to include non-financial measures in the performance measurement system. Recent literature in this area also suggests that organizations should place more emphasis on non-financial measures in their performance measurement systems; that organizations must use new performance measurement approaches; and that measures should be aligned with contextual factors such as strategy and organizational structure [6].…”

“…In the 1970s, researchers examined how organizations used management accounting systems especially budgeting as tools for performance measurement. In the 1980s, the focus was placed essentially on the budgeting process and its impact on performance [6]. Limitations of financial data as the basis for decision making in organisations has been recognised for a long time [7].…”

Factors Affecting Performance Manager and Its Impact on Competitive Advantage: Studies Small Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in The Shoes Industry Mojokerto East Java Province

“…It said further that the orientation of entrepreneurial orientation has a positive correlation with the performance of small businesses covering aspects: independence, innovation, courage to take risks, the aggressiveness of the competition and proactivity. Meanwhile, according to Gosselin (2005), that there is a significant relationship between entrepreneurial orientation defined by the company's performance. Entrepreneurial orientation refers to the processes, practices, and decision-making that led to the new input and has three aspects of entrepreneurship, that is willing to take risks, act proactively and always innovative (Lumpkin and Dess, 1996).…”

Measuring Performance - Conceptual Framework Questions

“…(Epstein and Manzoni, 1997) "The literature has suggested that firms should put much more emphasis on nonfinancial measures in comparison to financial measures … This study shows that … financial measures are much more used by controller than non-financial measures." (Gosselin, 2005) "Tracking things like customer satisfaction and employee turnover can powerfully supplement traditional bookkeeping. Unfortunately, most companies botch the job."…”