In a case study, we analyzed the development of a spatially extended eutrophic floating marsh in a mid-European river floodplain lake. Such buoyant fringe marshes occur occasionally in lakes or river floodplain waters which have accumulated considerable amounts of very soft organic sediments. There are two hypotheses about their formation: 1) diverse helophytes, among them Cicuta virosa and Carex pseudocyperus, colonize floating-leaf plant communities or floating plant residues washed ashore, and 2) normal reed stands detach from the soft lake bottom which then float up caused by their rhizome aerenchyma and by marsh gas accumulation. The following questions were pursued: 1) How did these floating peat mats develop and do they grow horizontally on the water surface? and 2) How will they develop in future? Our study is mainly based on the analysis of historical maps, aerial photographs, and the zonation of the riparian vegetation. In the first half of the 20th century, the formation of floating swamps began on the waterside edge of large reeds that had developed on huge mud banks. The succession proceeded at this edge to alder carr without substantial expansion toward the open water. This and other findings led us to the conclusion that the floating mat formation proceeds according to the second hypothesis. Since there is no significant horizontal growth of these floating marshes, the riparian vegetation belt of the lake will only spread by repeating the entire process.