American trees shift their niches when invading Western Europe: evaluating invasion risks in a changing climate

Abstract

Four North American trees are becoming invasive species in Western Europe: Acer negundo, Prunus serotina, Quercus rubra, and Robinia pseudoacacia. However, their present and future potential risks of invasion have not been yet evaluated. Here, we assess niche shifts between the native and invasive ranges and the potential invasion risk of these four trees in Western Europe. We estimated niche conservatism in a multidimensional climate space using niche overlap Schoener's D, niche equivalence, and niche similarity tests. Niche unfilling and expansion were also estimated in analogous and nonanalogous climates. The capacity for predicting the opposite range between the native and invasive areas (transferability) was estimated by calibrating species distribution models (SDMs) on each range separately. Invasion risk was estimated using SDMs calibrated on both ranges and projected for 2050 climatic conditions. Our results showed that native and invasive niches were not equivalent with low niche overlap for all species. However, significant similarity was found between the invasive and native ranges of Q. rubra and R. pseudoacacia. Niche expansion was lower than 15% for all species, whereas unfilling ranged from 7 to 56% when it was measured using the entire climatic space and between 5 and 38% when it was measured using analogous climate only. Transferability was low for all species. SDMs calibrated over both ranges projected high habitat suitability in Western Europe under current and future climates. Thus, the North American and Western European ranges are not interchangeable irrespective of the studied species, suggesting that other environmental and/or biological characteristics are shaping their invasive niches. The current climatic risk of invasion is especially high for R. pseudoacacia and A. negundo. In the future, the highest risks of invasion for all species are located in Central and Northern Europe, whereas the risk is likely to decrease in the Mediterranean basin.

How much does climate change threaten European forest tree species distributions?

“…Only 25% of them had projections for more than 10 species and 50% of them for only a single species. Most of the papers are focused on threatened species (e.g., Akhter et al., ), invasive species (e.g., Camenen, Porté, & Benito Garzón, ), or plantations (e.g., Li, Xu, Guo, & Du, ). Some broader studies concerned European (e.g., Sykes, Prentice, & Cramer, ) or American (e.g., Iverson, Prasad, Matthews, & Peters, ) forest tree species.…”

Genetic trials improve the transfer of Douglas‐fir distribution models across continents

“…Thus, their potential for applications under novel climates, or to be transferred to other region is limited (Randin et al 2006, Kearney et al 2010, Dormann et al 2012. Modeling the potential distribution of a species in its introduced range poses additional challenges for occurrence-based SDMs, such as non-availability of reliable occurrence data (Brus et al 2012) and lack of understanding of 'niche conservation' whereby species may or may not have similar niches in the native and introduced ranges (Broennimann et al 2007, Camenen et al 2016.…”

Adaptation of Forest Trees to Rapidly Changing Climate

“…It is possible that temperature conditions that occur in winter favor the perennation of powdery mildew fungi [118]. Moreover, cold winters limit overwintering of powdery mildew mycelia in leaves and buds [119] and cause limited survival of chasmothecia [120,121].…”