Along‐Strike Variation in the Magmatic Tempo of the Coast Mountains Batholith, British Columbia, and Implications for Processes Controlling Episodicity in Arcs
Abstract:The growth of the Coast Mountains batholith has been documented as episodic through time, and it has become a type example of a continental arc system that developed through non‐steady‐state magmatism. The magmatic record, however, is not well known along the length of the arc, hindering evaluation of the processes controlling the tempo and patterns of batholith growth. A new, robust geochronologic database (485 U‐Pb zircon and titanite ages, 120 of which are newly presented herein) covering nearly 1,000 km of… Show more
“…from ca. 120-80 Ma (Cecil et al, 2018). This rate, age, and direction of arc migration are also shared by the Sierra Nevada and Peninsular Range batholiths, which are interpreted to have faced to the west in nearly all Cordilleran syntheses.…”
Recent syntheses of Cordillera tectonics contain contradictory views of subduction polarity in the late Mesozoic, and this contradiction has implications for whole-earth processes. The long-held view of eastdipping subduction throughout the Late Jurassic-Early Cretaceous Cordillera is challenged by tectonic models calling on a west-dipping subduction system that led to the collision of oceanic arcs, ribboncontinents, or both, with North America. Evidence in support of these models are seismic anomalies in the deep mantle inferred to represent subducted lithosphere from a west-dipping slab. We argue that this "bottom-up" approach to tectonic synthesis carries assumptions that are as great as or greater than ambiguities from the "topdown" approach of surface geology. Geologic evidence from the northern Cordillera is inconsistent with west-dipping subduction in Jura-Cretaceous time and requires long-lived east-dipping subduction along much of the Cordilleran margin. West-dipping subduction in Triassic-Early Jurassic time has been documented and may be the source of the seismic anomalies. We encourage the broader community to come to consensus on integration of these deep images with surface geology. FUNDAMENTAL CONTROVERSY OF SUBDUCTION POLARITY Uncertainties regarding the late Mesozoic evolution of the Cordilleran margin focus primarily on (1) the size of the ocean basin separating the Wrangellia composite terrane (WCT) or Insular superterrane from the continental margin; and (2) the location, polarity, and age of subduction zones that closed this basin (Fig. 1). One set of models, mainly based on geologic observations, shares an interpretation that this basin closed during Jura-Cretaceous time along an east-dipping 1 subduction zone built along the continental margin,
“…from ca. 120-80 Ma (Cecil et al, 2018). This rate, age, and direction of arc migration are also shared by the Sierra Nevada and Peninsular Range batholiths, which are interpreted to have faced to the west in nearly all Cordilleran syntheses.…”
Recent syntheses of Cordillera tectonics contain contradictory views of subduction polarity in the late Mesozoic, and this contradiction has implications for whole-earth processes. The long-held view of eastdipping subduction throughout the Late Jurassic-Early Cretaceous Cordillera is challenged by tectonic models calling on a west-dipping subduction system that led to the collision of oceanic arcs, ribboncontinents, or both, with North America. Evidence in support of these models are seismic anomalies in the deep mantle inferred to represent subducted lithosphere from a west-dipping slab. We argue that this "bottom-up" approach to tectonic synthesis carries assumptions that are as great as or greater than ambiguities from the "topdown" approach of surface geology. Geologic evidence from the northern Cordillera is inconsistent with west-dipping subduction in Jura-Cretaceous time and requires long-lived east-dipping subduction along much of the Cordilleran margin. West-dipping subduction in Triassic-Early Jurassic time has been documented and may be the source of the seismic anomalies. We encourage the broader community to come to consensus on integration of these deep images with surface geology. FUNDAMENTAL CONTROVERSY OF SUBDUCTION POLARITY Uncertainties regarding the late Mesozoic evolution of the Cordilleran margin focus primarily on (1) the size of the ocean basin separating the Wrangellia composite terrane (WCT) or Insular superterrane from the continental margin; and (2) the location, polarity, and age of subduction zones that closed this basin (Fig. 1). One set of models, mainly based on geologic observations, shares an interpretation that this basin closed during Jura-Cretaceous time along an east-dipping 1 subduction zone built along the continental margin,
“…Black arrows show interpreted crustal evolution trajectories assuming present-day 176 Lu/ 177 Hf = 0.0093 (Vervoort and Patchett,1996;Bahlburg et al, 2011). (Gehrels et al, 2009) and Southern Coast Mountain Batholith (Cecil et al, 2018) are represented with dashed lines. Reference lines on the Hf plot are as follows: DM-depleted mantle, calculated using 176 Hf/ 177 Hf0 = 0.283225 and 176 Lu/ 177 Hf0 = 0.038512 (Vervoort and Blichert-Toft,1999); CHUR-chondritic uniform reservoir, calculated using 176 Hf/ 177 Hf = 0.282785 and 176 Lu/ 177 Hf = 0.0336 (Bouvier et al, 2008).…”
Wrangellia, an exotic arc terrane to North America, is interpreted to have been constructed near the margin of the Paleo-Arctic and Paleo-Pacific during middle-late Paleozoic time, before finally accreting to the western margin of North America during Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous time. Utilizing the detrital zircon record of Paleozoic sedimentary rocks and Cretaceous basin fill we can provide further insight into the magmatic and depositional evolution of southern Wrangellia. 1422 U-Pb LA-ICPMS analyses from five samples of the Fourth Lake Formation in the Carboniferous Buttle Lake Group were performed. 1055 U-Pb LA-ICPMS analyses from four samples of the Comox formation within the Cretaceous Nanaimo Group were acquired in order to provide a broader sampling of the Lower Mesozoic-Paleozoic rocks of Vancouver Island. U-Pb analyses within the Fourth Lake Formation reveal prominent Carboniferous age peaks (344, 339, 336, 331, and 317 Ma), with minor pre-400 Ma grains from adjacent terranes of Paleo-Arctic origin. Paleozoic detrital zircons exhibit juvenile, with ƐHf (t) values between +15 and +5. U-Pb analyses of Nanaimo Group sedimentary rocks reveal dominant peak ages at 341, 195, 167, and 86 Ma. All major populations yield juvenile epsilon ƐHf (t) values in the range of +15 to +6. The detrital zircon U-Pb geochronologic and Hf isotope data in this study suggest that sediment from the Fourth Lake Formation was derived mainly from bimodal magmatism within the Paleozoic southern Wrangellia arc system as well as minor 6 contributions of recycled detritus from the adjacent Alexander Terrane. Hf isotope data from the Comox Formation indicate that Triassic and Jurassic igneous rocks of the Bonanza Arc, and Late Jurassic-Early Cretaceous sources from the central Coast Mountains Batholith (CMB), are highly juvenile. This new geochronologic and geochemical data set contributes to a new tectonic model for the Paleozoic Southern Wrangellia Arc system from Late Devonian to Early Permian time and reveals, during Cretaceous time, very locally derived detritus was deposited in sedimentary basins along the inboard margin of Wrangellia.
“…In southern Alaska, these igneous products include the Early to Late Jurassic Talkeetna arc (Rioux et al, 2007), the Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous Chitina arc (Plafker and Berg, 1994), and the Early Cretaceous Chisana arc (Barker et al, 1994). In southeastern Alaska and northern coastal British Columbia, arc plutons within the Insular terranes comprise the western Coast Mountains batholith (Gehrels et al, 2009;Cecil et al, 2011Cecil et al, , 2018. The allochthonous Yakutat terrane is faulted against the outboard edge of the Chugach terrane and has been subducting at a shallow angle beneath the subduction complex and Insular terranes since Neogene time (e.g., Enkelmann et al, 2010;Worthington et al, 2012;Arkle et al, 2013).…”
“…Eastern Gravina belt strata accumulated along the western margin of the Stikine, Yukon-Tanana, and Taku terranes. The history of juxtaposition of western and eastern assemblages is obscured by subsequent plutonism, deformation, and metamorphism within the Coast Mountains orogeny (Gehrels et al, 2009;Cecil et al, 2011Cecil et al, , 2018.…”
Section: U-pb Ages Of Detrital Zircons Indicate That Kahiltnamentioning
The Nutzotin basin of eastern Alaska consists of Upper Jurassic through Lower Cretaceous siliciclastic sedimentary and volcanic rocks that depositionally overlie the inboard margin of Wrangellia, an accreted oceanic plateau. We present igneous geochronologic data from volcanic rocks and detrital geochronologic and paleontological data from nonmarine sedimentary strata that provide constraints on the timing of deposition and sediment provenance. We also report geochronologic data from a dike injected into the Totschunda fault zone, which provides constraints on the timing of intra–suture zone basinal deformation. The Beaver Lake formation is an important sedimentary succession in the northwestern Cordillera because it provides an exceptionally rare stratigraphic record of the transition from marine to nonmarine depositional conditions along the inboard margin of the Insular terranes during mid-Cretaceous time. Conglomerate, volcanic-lithic sandstone, and carbonaceous mudstone/shale accumulated in fluvial channel-bar complexes and vegetated overbank areas, as evidenced by lithofacies data, the terrestrial nature of recovered kerogen and palynomorph assemblages, and terrestrial macrofossil remains of ferns and conifers. Sediment was eroded mainly from proximal sources of upper Jurassic to lower Cretaceous igneous rocks, given the dominance of detrital zircon and amphibole grains of that age, plus conglomerate with chiefly volcanic and plutonic clasts. Deposition was occurring by ca. 117 Ma and ceased by ca. 98 Ma, judging from palynomorphs, the youngest detrital ages, and ages of crosscutting intrusions and underlying lavas of the Chisana Formation. Following deposition, the basin fill was deformed, partly eroded, and displaced laterally by dextral displacement along the Totschunda fault, which bisects the Nutzotin basin. The Totschunda fault initiated by ca. 114 Ma, as constrained by the injection of an alkali feldspar syenite dike into the Totschunda fault zone.
These results support previous interpretations that upper Jurassic to lower Cretaceous strata in the Nutzotin basin accumulated along the inboard margin of Wrangellia in a marine basin that was deformed during mid-Cretaceous time. The shift to terrestrial sedimentation overlapped with crustal-scale intrabasinal deformation of Wrangellia, based on previous studies along the Lost Creek fault and our new data from the Totschunda fault. Together, the geologic evidence for shortening and terrestrial deposition is interpreted to reflect accretion/suturing of the Insular terranes against inboard terranes. Our results also constrain the age of previously reported dinosaur footprints to ca. 117 Ma to ca. 98 Ma, which represent the only dinosaur fossils reported from eastern Alaska.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.