Aging of theory of mind: The influence of educational level and cognitive processing

Abstract

Previous studies of theory of mind (ToM) in old age have provided mixed results. We predicted that educational level and cognitive processing are two factors influencing the pattern of the aging of ToM. To test this hypothesis, a younger group who received higher education (mean age 20.46 years), an older group with an education level equal to that of the young group (mean age 76.29 years), and an older group with less education (mean age 73.52 years) were recruited. ToM tasks included the following tests: the second-order false-belief task, the faux-pas task, the eyes test, and tests of fundamental aspects of cognitive function that included two background tests (memory span and processing speed) and three subcomponents of executive function (inhibition, updating, and shifting). We found that the younger group and the older group with equally high education outperformed the older group with less education in false-belief and faux-pas tasks. However, there was no significant difference between the two former groups. The three groups of participants performed equivalently in the eyes test as well as in control tasks (false-belief control question, faux-pas control question, faux-pas control story, and Eyes Test control task). The younger group outperformed the other two groups in the cognitive processing tasks. Mediation analyses showed that difficulties in inhibition, memory span, and processing speed mediated the age differences in false-belief reasoning. Also, the variables of inhibition, updating, memory span, and processing speed mediated age-related variance in faux-pas. Discussion focused on the links between ToM aging, educational level, and cognitive processing. Supported by Chinese National Natural Science Foundation (number: 30870766) and Anhui Province Natural Science Foundation (number: 11040606M166).

Dysregulation between emotion and theory of mind networks in borderline personality disorder

“…Thus, it is possible that the education difference in an age-matched cohort may reflect the burden of the disorder, whilst a sample matched with respect to level of education could result in sample bias. Conversely, there is also reason to believe that level of education may impact individual performance on ToM tasks, contradicting the current findings (Li et al, 2013). This complex and as yet undefined relationship between level of education and ToM ability makes it difficult to fully discern the affecting factors, and is a limitation of the present study.…”

A novel task assessing intention and emotion attribution: Italian standardization and normative data of the Story-based Empathy Task

“…This result is consistent with previous studies showing that cognitive ageing is accompanied by a decline in mentalizing abilities [27], which in turn are related to educational level [28]. In contrast, gender has no effect on SET performance, a result in agreement with previous reports of a female advantage in empathic abilities limited to emotional empathy [29].…”

An investigation on the effectiveness of chess training on creativity and theory of mind development at early childhood

“…ToM is correlated with social cognitive skills, and these skills have impacts on understanding beliefs and intensions as well as interpreting the mental state of other people (Li et al, 2013). Most researchers considered that there is a single transition in children's understanding of mental states which was a change they experience between 3 and 4 years of age or a change experienced from before to after an interpreting a false belief (Bartsch and Wellman, 1995).…”