Accountability and the rise of “play safe” pedagogical practices

Abstract

Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to examine how the culture of teacher accountability has been intensified in further education (FE) under neo-liberalist policy, with the result that the student-teacher relationship has shifted to one of supplier-consumer. The paper focuses on the impact which this shift has had on teachers' pedagogical practice and employment prospects. Design/methodology/approach -The paper draws on data gathered during a three-year ethnographic study which focused on the experiences of trainee and newly qualified teachers working in the FE sector. The data were generated from naturally occurring evidence including reflective diaries, lesson observations and class discussions. Findings -The findings suggest that target-driven college cultures are creating conditions which encourage teachers to "play safe" in terms of pedagogical practice whilst students are becoming increasingly dependent on teacher-led direction in a bid to achieve targets. Not only are teachers being held increasingly accountable for their students' results but their employment prospects are also dependent on them.Research limitations/implications -Although based on a small-scale study, the findings are of sufficient significance to stimulate debate and future research around the issue of how neo-liberalist policy impacts on practice in FE. Practical implications -The paper suggests that for both FE teachers and their students, creative thinking and experimentation may be at risk from the impact of such policy. Originality/value -This paper goes beyond existing critiques of accountability: it argues that as teachers' employment prospects become increasingly dependent on student results, both teachers and their students are vulnerable to focusing on risk-free practices which jeopardise the potential for innovation and autonomy.

Reconstrucciones “Resilientes” de la Identidad Profesional del Profesorado: Endoprivatización y Cultura Performativa en Andalucía (España)

“…En este sentido, para mitigar las tensiones de identidad que plantean las prácticas neoliberales de endoprivatización, los docentes intentan reconciliar sus axiomas personales y profesionales con los requerimientos de la cultura del rendimiento. Una parte del profesorado apuesta por adoptar prácticas más seguras, orientadas a que el alumnado obtenga mejores resultados, en un intento de cumplir con las exigencias demandadas (Bailey, 2014):…”

Um novo olhar sobre a vida acadêmica: estudo de caso sobre as concepções de docentes

“…Na prática, a FP é observada quando os acadêmicos, frente às pressões cumulativas do ambiente profissional, têm reduzida a sua capacidade de alterar práticas de ensino em resposta a um ambiente em constante transformação (KINCHIN et al, 2016). Nesse contexto, a adoção de uma abordagem pedagógica segura e sustentável caracteriza-se como o único caminho possível (CLEGG, 2008;BAILEY, 2014).…”

Visualising the pedagogic frailty model as a frame for the scholarship of teaching and learning

“…These tensions have been shown to discourage innovation in teaching and result in a conservative maintenance of "safe" or "traditional" practices (Bailey, 2014). Frailty is, therefore, not a characteristic of an individual academic, but a feature of the wider educational system that may not function optimally as a result of hidden and unarticulated tensions.…”