A word in the hand: action, gesture and mental representation in humans and non-human primates

Abstract

The movements we make with our hands both reflect our mental processes and help to shape them. Our actions and gestures can affect our mental representations of actions and objects. In this paper, we explore the relationship between action, gesture and thought in both humans and non-human primates and discuss its role in the evolution of language. Human gesture (specifically representational gesture) may provide a unique link between action and mental representation. It is kinaesthetically close to action and is, at the same time, symbolic. Non-human primates use gesture frequently to communicate, and do so flexibly. However, their gestures mainly resemble incomplete actions and lack the representational elements that characterize much of human gesture. Differences in the mirror neuron system provide a potential explanation for non-human primates' lack of representational gestures; the monkey mirror system does not respond to representational gestures, while the human system does. In humans, gesture grounds mental representation in action, but there is no evidence for this link in other primates. We argue that gesture played an important role in the transition to symbolic thought and language in human evolution, following a cognitive leap that allowed gesture to incorporate representational elements.

Does dysfunction of the mirror neuron system contribute to symptoms in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis?

“…It has been proposed that gesture and speech form a single system of communication, because they are linked to the same thought processes, even if expressed differently (Arbib et al , 2008, Cartmill et al , 2012, Eisen et al , 2014b. Observing and executing the grasp of small and large objects, for example a grape versus an apple, changes the degree of mouth opening and simultaneously pronunciation of syllables (Gentilucci et al , 2008b).…”

Widening the lens: what the manual modality reveals about language, learning and cognition

“…B 369: 20130295 that the analogue information must be conveyed in the manual modality. The manual modality may be privileged when it comes to expressing emergent or mimetic ideas, perhaps because our hands are an important vehicle for discovering properties of the world [98][99][100].…”

Contemplative Inquiry in Movement: Managing Writer´s Block in Academic Writing

“…Acceptance of personal events may be supported by bodily movements, as bodily positions and movements can act as symbolic cues to memory and support the holding of information and experiences in conscious awareness (i.e., in working memory). In support of this, it has been shown that working memory performance can improve if bodily gestures are also utilized to aid in imprinting memories (Cartmill, Beilock, & Goldin-Meadow, 2012).…”