A Web Interface for Antibiotic Prescription Recommendations in Primary Care: User-Centered Design Approach

Abstract

Background Antibiotic misuse is a serious public health problem worldwide. National health authorities release clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) to guide general practitioners (GPs) in their choice of antibiotics. However, despite the large-scale dissemination of CPGs, GPs continue to prescribe antibiotics that are not recommended as first-line treatments. This nonadherence to recommendations may be due to GPs misunderstanding the CPGs. A web interface displaying antibiotic prescription recommendations and their justifications could help to improve the comprehensibility and readability of CPGs, thereby increasing the adoption of recommendations regarding antibiotic treatment. Objective This study aims to design and evaluate a web interface for antibiotic prescription displaying both the recommended antibiotics and their justifications in the form of antibiotic properties. Methods A web interface was designed according to the same principles as e-commerce interfaces and was assessed by 117 GPs. These GPs were asked to answer 17 questions relating to the usefulness, user-friendliness, and comprehensibility and readability of the interface, and their satisfaction with it. Responses were recorded on a 4-point Likert scale (ranging from “absolutely disagree” to “absolutely agree”). At the end of the evaluation, the GPs were allowed to provide optional, additional free comments. Results The antibiotic prescription web interface consists of three main sections: a clinical summary section, a filter section, and a recommended antibiotics section. The majority of GPs appreciated the clinical summary (90/117, 76.9%) and filter (98/117, 83.8%) sections, whereas 48.7% (57/117) of them reported difficulty reading some of the icons in the recommended antibiotics section. Overall, 82.9% (97/117) of GPs found the display of drug properties useful, and 65.8% (77/117) reported that the web interface improved their understanding of CPG recommendations. Conclusions The web interface displaying antibiotic recommendations and their properties can help doctors understand the rationale underlying CPG recommendations regarding antibiotic treatment, but further improvements are required before its implementation into a clinical decision support system.

Comments by Microbiologists for Interpreting Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing and Improving the Appropriateness of Antibiotic Therapy in Community-Acquired Urinary Tract Infections: A Randomized Double-Blind Digital Case-Vignette Controlled Superiority Trial

“…However, the concealment of allocation was ensured, and the randomization process allowed us to properly balance case vignettes between arms. Moreover, we did not use a user-centered approach in our pilot study conducted before the trial to ensure that the understanding of ‘comments’ was optimal [ 39 ]. Finally, although we did not conduct the trial in real-life settings, digital trials are deemed acceptable for the evaluation of interventions on antibiotic appropriateness [ 40 , 41 ].…”

Towards a Clinical Decision Support System for Helping Medical Students in Emergency Call Centers

“…Second, the interface may appear too complex because of high quantity of text (due to our will to provide a maximum of information to medical students to overcome their lack of medical skills). In the future we plan to use other design techniques such as icons for limiting the quantity of text [11].…”