A Systematic Review of the Research Papers on Chemistry-Focused Socio-Scientific Issues

Abstract

Although chemistry-focused socio-scientific issues support the ‘relevance’ model of chemistry education, the related literature has lacked any systematic review handling them together. For this reason, this research aimed to thematically synthesize the research papers on chemistry-focused socio scientific issues (SSI) from 2008 to 2020 and inferentially evaluate them in terms of the relevance model of chemistry education. After searching international and national well-known databases through relevant keyword patterns (e.g., Pattern 1: socio-scientific issues and chemistry education), 65 research papers were apparent for the systematic review. Then, the authors generated primary and secondary codes for the research papers and then inferentially marked their ‘relevance’ components. The systematic review indicated variation of research areas (e.g., relevance model of chemistry education) and dominant research foci for different themes (e.g., competencies and related variables for the theme ‘aims’; pollution, energy, industry and fabrication-based problems for the theme ‘SSI’; organic compounds for the theme ‘chemistry concepts’). Further, it revealed that the research papers on chemistry-focused SSI had some shortcomings at handling all components of the relevance model in a balanced way. The current research suggests professionally training teachers about how to integrate chemistry-focused SSI and the relevance model into school chemistry. Keywords: chemistry education, relevance model, socio-scientific issues, systematic review

Discursive Formed Topics in Information Literacy: Literature Review and High School Students' Perspectives

“…The study was divided into two phases -the first offered a systematic review of the literature (Çalık & Wiyarsi, 2021;Goes et al, 2020) in information literacy and high schools in the last three years . The second compared the results of this review with the focus group conducted with high school students.…”

Development of Argumentation Based Concept Cartoons for Socioscientific Issues: A Case of Science and Art Centers

“…Ayrıca, SBK hakkındaki karar verme süreçlerinde aktif rol almanın bir vatandaşlık görevi olarak görülmesinden dolayı (Aikenhead, 1985;Barrue ve Albe, 2013;Kolsto, 2001), sorumlu vatandaşların yetiştirilmesinde eğitimin önemli olduğu düşüncesi eğitimsel katkının bariz bir şekilde ortaya çıkmasını sağlamış olabilir. Örneğin; fen derslerinde SBK'nin fen okuryazarlığı ve sorumlu vatandaşlık bağlamında bir araç olarak kullanılması bunun bir göstergesi olarak kabul edilebilir (Çalık ve Wiyarsi, 2021;Topcu vd., 2014). GDO, nükleer enerji, nehir tipi HES ve uzay kirliliği konularının hem ortaokul hem de lise öğrencileri için uygun olduğu ortaya çıkmıştır.…”

“…Bireylerin SBK ile ilgili bilimsel gerekçeler göstererek görüş bildirme, farklı bilimsel gerekçelerle desteklenen görüşler arasında değerlendirme yapabilme ve akılcı karar verme süreçlerinde yer almaları bir vatandaşlık görevidir (Aikenhead, 1985;Barrue ve Albe, 2013;Kolsto, 2001). Bu bireylerin yetiştirilmesi fen okuryazarlığının bir gereği olduğundan, SBK'nin amaç ve/veya araç olarak fen öğretiminde kullanılması önem arz etmektedir (Çalık ve Wiyarsi, 2021;Topcu, Muğaloğlu ve Güven, 2014). SBK'nin fen okuryazarlığına ve sorumlu vatandaşlık bilincinin gelişmesine katkı sağlamasından dolayı, öğrencilerin SBK ile ilgili karar verme becerilerinin geliştirilmesi Türkiye'de (Milli Eğitim Bakanlığı [MEB], 2018) olduğu gibi Amerika Birleşik Devletleri (21st Century Science Project Team, 2003; American Association for the Advancement of Science [AAAS], 1989;National Research Council [NRC], 1996), Endonezya (Nida, Mustikasari ve Eilks, 2021), Tayvan (Ministry of Education [MOE], 1998), İsveç (Lpf 94, 1994) gibi diğer birçok ülkenin öğretim programlarına da girmiştir.…”

Using the Covid-19 Pandemic as a Socioscientific Issue to Support the Scientific Habits of Mind

“…Thus, they are able to think, understand, decide and make an action about any urgent event or "forced" transition, i.e., the pandemic process (Rodgríguez et al, 2021). Unfortunately, the COVID-19 pandemic seems to have generated a climate of fear for scientific advances and mass vaccination as well as regulations on lockdown, socialization, and hygiene.Given the foregoing features, the COVID-19 pandemic typically involves debate among scientists, politicians, and citizens when decision making about the use of science and regulations (Çalık & Wiyarsi, 2021). Phrased differently, the COVID-19 pandemic incorporates the related classification features of socio-scientific issues (e.g., holding different key beliefs/views/values, and lack of a scientific consensus) (Çalik & Coll, 2012).…”

“…Given the foregoing features, the COVID-19 pandemic typically involves debate among scientists, politicians, and citizens when decision making about the use of science and regulations (Çalık & Wiyarsi, 2021). Phrased differently, the COVID-19 pandemic incorporates the related classification features of socio-scientific issues (e.g., holding different key beliefs/views/values, and lack of a scientific consensus) (Çalik & Coll, 2012).…”