A statistical mechanics approach to mixing in stratified fluids

Abstract

Predicting how much mixing occurs when a given amount of energy is injected into a Boussinesq fluid is a longstanding problem in stratified turbulence. The huge number of degrees of freedom involved in these processes renders extremely difficult a deterministic approach to the problem. Here we present a statistical mechanics approach yielding a prediction for a cumulative, global mixing efficiency as a function of a global Richardson number and the background buoyancy profile. Assuming random evolution through turbulent stirring, the theory predicts that the inviscid, adiabatic dynamics is attracted irreversibly towards an equilibrium state characterised by a smooth, stable buoyancy profile at a coarse-grained level, upon which are fine-scale fluctuations of velocity and buoyancy. The convergence towards a coarse-grained buoyancy profile different from the initial one corresponds to an irreversible increase of potential energy, and the efficiency of mixing is quantified as the ratio of this potential energy increase to the total energy injected into the system. The remaining part of the energy is literally lost into small-scale fluctuations. We show that for sufficiently large Richardson number, there is equipartition between potential and kinetic energy, provided that the background buoyancy profile is strictly monotonic. This yields a mixing efficiency of 0.25, which provides statistical mechanics support for previous predictions based on phenomenological kinematics arguments. In the general case, the cumulative, global mixing efficiency predicted by the equilibrium theory can be computed using an algorithm based on a maximum entropy production principle. It is shown in particular that the variation of mixing efficiency with the Richardson number strongly depends on the background buoyancy profile. This approach could be useful to the understanding of mixing in stratified turbulence in the limit of large Reynolds and Péclet numbers.

Harmonic to subharmonic transition of the Faraday instability in miscible fluids

“…The second definition can be found in Refs. [10,21,23] and is based on the background potential energy, so that it should be more relevant in terms of quantifying the irreversible mixing. The instantaneous mixing efficiency reads…”

Layer formation in horizontally forced stratified turbulence: connecting exact coherent structures to linear instabilities

“…Alternatively, Balmforth et al (1998) proposed that the relationship between buoyancy flux and stratification should be 'N-shaped', with a return to an increase in buoyancy flux with increasing and sufficiently large stratification. Indeed, the possibly non-monotonic dependence of irreversible buoyancy flux on external parameters is a very active area of research controversy (see e.g Venayagamoorthy & Koseff (2016); Venaille et al (2016); Maffioli et al (2016)). Importantly however, the fundamental physical mechanisms leading to either the formation or the maintenance of layered density distributions are still quite open.…”

Diapycnal mixing in layered stratified plane Couette flow quantified in a tracer-based coordinate

“…Recently, statistical mechanics arguments developed by Venaille et al (2017), assuming infinite Reynolds and Péclet numbers, suggest that some appropriate measure of the overall mixing efficiency, characterising the fraction of the kinetic energy loss by the fluid that leads an irreversibly gain in the potential energy due to mixing, varies non-monotonically with the overall gradient Richardson number if the background buoyancy profile contains a layered structure, whereas such a mixing efficiency asymptotes to a constant value of approximately 0.25 if the background buoyancy gradient is uniform. This suggests that the mixing properties of a sharp density interface may vary significantly from that of a linearly varying density profile (e.g.…”