“…All of these aptitudes are engaged by PBL field exercises such as the one described here and others that seek to develop the concept of 'the expanded classroom' for experiential education (McEwen et al, 2003;Katula and Threnhauser, 1999). The main issue here is whether or not it is better to try and create this broad vision within each individual learner or to teach that learner to become used to working in multidisciplinary teams that collectively deploy the broad sustainability understanding needed by environmental professionals (Meehan and Thomas, 2006). In fact, the two approaches are not discrete and these results show that this kind of individual work has the side-effect of encouraging team-working as a voluntary strategy.…”
Reductions in the fieldwork component of many environmental curricula mean that graduates have less practical experience. This paper attempts to compensate by developing a short, intensive, highly structured field exercise that aims to connect classroom theory to field realities in the context of the management of reclaimed coal-land. A self-paced field trail guides learners, first to examine land degradation processes in detail and then to tackle larger sustainability issues. The problems that learners encounter include difficulties in understanding the mind-sets of either landscape designers or land users and of comprehending landscape process dynamics. Nevertheless, learners value the first hand experience, the realisation that real-world answers are not always simple, that prior learning is essential to effective field interpretation, that teamwork is a problem-solving tool and that these skills require 'practice'. Learners who score well in fieldwork also scored well in class quizzes, spoken presentations, essays, other field projects and formal examinations.
“…All of these aptitudes are engaged by PBL field exercises such as the one described here and others that seek to develop the concept of 'the expanded classroom' for experiential education (McEwen et al, 2003;Katula and Threnhauser, 1999). The main issue here is whether or not it is better to try and create this broad vision within each individual learner or to teach that learner to become used to working in multidisciplinary teams that collectively deploy the broad sustainability understanding needed by environmental professionals (Meehan and Thomas, 2006). In fact, the two approaches are not discrete and these results show that this kind of individual work has the side-effect of encouraging team-working as a voluntary strategy.…”
Reductions in the fieldwork component of many environmental curricula mean that graduates have less practical experience. This paper attempts to compensate by developing a short, intensive, highly structured field exercise that aims to connect classroom theory to field realities in the context of the management of reclaimed coal-land. A self-paced field trail guides learners, first to examine land degradation processes in detail and then to tackle larger sustainability issues. The problems that learners encounter include difficulties in understanding the mind-sets of either landscape designers or land users and of comprehending landscape process dynamics. Nevertheless, learners value the first hand experience, the realisation that real-world answers are not always simple, that prior learning is essential to effective field interpretation, that teamwork is a problem-solving tool and that these skills require 'practice'. Learners who score well in fieldwork also scored well in class quizzes, spoken presentations, essays, other field projects and formal examinations.
“…As previously noted, such issues usually defy disciplinary boundaries and, as such, projects in PjBL are often interdisciplinary (Frank & Barzilai, 2004;Jarmon, Traphagan, & Mayrath, 2008;Nation, 2008;Stauffacher et al, 2006) or work in collaboration with external organisations (Moehr, Protti, Lau, & Grimm, 2004;von Kotze & Cooper, 2000). Projects often conclude with the creation of a tangible end-product (Danford, 2006), which may incorporate a useful social function (Meehan & Thomas, 2006).The approach is practiced across a wide range of disciplines but is particularly prevalent in engineering (Harmer & Stokes, 2014), arguably because of the inherently interdisciplinary nature of the subject and its emphasis on the collaborative creation of a material end product (Otake et al, 2009).…”
Section: Project-based Learning As a Student-centred Pedagogical Apprmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…In GEES disciplines approaches such as PBL (Beringer, 2007;Pawson et al, 2006) and IBL (Spronken-Smith & Kingham, 2009) are more commonly applied at undergraduate level, and as such the literature on PjBL in geography and related disciplines is relatively sparse (Nation, 2008). The few examples of PjBL within the GEES disciplines tend to focus on graduate students and/or to explore the interdisciplinary subject area of sustainability (Brundiers & Wiek, 2013;Kilinç, 2010;Meehan & Thomas, 2006;Nation, 2008). Projectbased learning eludes a clear and precise definition, but for the purposes of this study is defined as "an activity in which students develop an understanding of a topic or issue through some type of involvement in an actual (or simulated) real-life problem or issue and in which they have some degree of responsibility in designing their learning activities" (Morgan, 1983, p. 66).…”
Section: Project-based Learning As a Student-centred Pedagogical Apprmentioning
Choice may not necessarily be a good thing": student attitudes to autonomy in interdisciplinary project-based learning in GEES disciplines Harmer, NA Harmer, N. and Stokes, A. "Choice may not necessarily be a good thing": Student attitudes to autonomy in interdisciplinary project-based learning in GEES disciplines.
AbstractProject-based learning (PjBL) is argued to foster a more democratic approach to education, particularly through increasing students' autonomy over their learning. This article presents the findings of research into students' views relating to autonomy over topic choice and group constitution during a series of trial interdisciplinary project-based learning activities with first year geography, earth and environmental sciences (GEES) undergraduates in a UK university. Semi-structured interviews with participating students and tutors, in addition to audio-recordings of staff-student discussion during student-led presentation sessions, formed the dataset analysed for this article. Findings suggest that while some degree of autonomy was welcomed, participants largely favoured prescription regarding research question and group membership. This has implications for the implementation of PjBL and its potential to foster democratisation within the GEES disciplines.
“…Meehan and Thomas (2006) used project-based learning to teach teamwork and interdisciplinary skills to students working on environmental development projects in Vietnam. Management educators have used case studies involving Canada's National Round Tables on Environment and Economy (Egri, 1999), protection of the northern spotted owl under the Endangered Species Act (Tucker & Tromley, 2002), regulation of solvent-contaminated cleaning rags under the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA; Ramus, 2003), and environmental levies on beer under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade and the World Trade Organization (Doh, 2004).…”
Section: Introductionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Adopting assumed roles, students simulate the penalty negotiation process between corporate representatives and federal and state environmental officials. The exercise can be adapted for high schools or professional development short courses, 1 and it is designed to provide an accessible, workplacerelated learning experience that helps students link academic theories with real-world knowledge (Meehan & Thomas, 2006).…”
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.